What fighters do you consider to be "has beens" or "past their prime"?

[Sparked_1985]

Judah was an undisputed champion at one point. Pretty damn good.

Just not as good as he thinks he is. Which is with the PBF's of this world.

That's what I get from Zab anyway, that's why he takes these fights against bigger, stronger men, where he doesn't have the strength to compete or the defence to overcome it.

That said Hatton would probably beat him at 140 anyway,

[cbbulldog]

Judah was an undisputed champion at one point. Pretty damn good.

Just not as good as he thinks he is. Which is with the PBF's of this world.

That's what I get from Zab anyway, that's why he takes these fights against bigger, stronger men, where he doesn't have the strength to compete or the defence to overcome it.

That said Hatton would probably beat him at 140 anyway,

I agree hatton probably would beat him. Sometimes it seems like it's easy to break his spirit.

[rape]

I would like to see Zab suceed but like you said it seems he doesn't try.

[larryx]

i dont think jermain taylor will ever be what he was

[Underdog82]

I vote Zab Judah. Some disagree but he's a has been as far as I am concerned. When the pressure is on and a fight really matters he does this crumple up and fail routine over and over. He's never stepped up to the bat and hit a homerun when it mattered most.

Who would you say is a has been or past their prime that some disagree with?

Zab Judah can't be a "has been" when he never was. He was a journyman with potential that wasn't able to break the elite barrier. He got more shots than he deserved and failed over and over again.

Stop making these threads as if this kid was some sort of ATG. There is no shortage of up and coming boxers like Judah that just don't make it and become forgotten. He is insignificant.

[larryx]

Zab Judah can't be a "has been" when he never was. He was a journyman with potential that wasn't able to break the elite barrier. He got more shots than he deserved and failed over and over again.

Stop making these threads as if this kid was some sort of ATG. There is no shortage of up and coming boxers like Judah that just don't make it and become forgotten. He is insignificant.

a never was journey man???he's a 2 division champ and was undisputed at 147??

[Underdog82]

I would like to see Zab suceed but like you said it seems he doesn't try.

Bull****. I see far to much of this crap spouted about Judah on the internet.

Of course he tried and tried hard. He just doesn't have it. It's that simple.

[rape]

You seem angry. Lay off the steroids.

[joseph5620]

The thing about Kermit is, he's got a lot of power but he just isn't that good.
He went life and death with a few guys he should've handled and Margarito had his number, so the thing is he's not past prime, he is just what he is.
A flawed guy with some pop.

Exactly. That sums it up perfectly.