What fighters do you consider to be "has beens" or "past their prime"?

[rape]

I vote Zab Judah. Some disagree but he's a has been as far as I am concerned. When the pressure is on and a fight really matters he does this crumple up and fail routine over and over. He's never stepped up to the bat and hit a homerun when it mattered most.

Who would you say is a has been or past their prime that some disagree with?

[THRILLA77]

na zab just needs to fight people his size

[MR.CHICANITO]

I vote Zab Judah. Some disagree but he's a has been as far as I am concerned. When the pressure is on and a fight really matters he does this crumple up and fail routine over and over. He's never stepped up to the bat and hit a homerun when it mattered most.

Who would you say is a has been or past their prime that some disagree with?

i think you can call paulie malinagee that he lost his big fights to miguel cotto and ricky hatton..he should haved at least won one of them

[rape]

i think you can call paulie malinagee that he lost his big fights to miguel cotto and ricky hatton..he should haved at least won one of them

Agreed. Malignaggi is another star that burned out kind of quickly. Not saying I never wanna see him fight again but I think his fight with Hatton is the biggest fight he will ever get at this point.

[MANGLER]

Sam Peter's time as a star and fighter to be feared at HW is over. I don't see him goin anywhere anymore.

[MR.CHICANITO]

Agreed. Malignaggi is another star that burned out kind of quickly. Not saying I never wanna see him fight again but I think his fight with Hatton is the biggest fight he will ever get at this point.

another fighter who has always had the potential has got to be kermit cintron that guy seems like he either chokes under pressure or something ..who knows ? maybe he just dont got it

[Guest]

another fighter who has always had the potential has got to be kermit cintron that guy seems like he either chokes under pressure or something ..who knows ? maybe he just dont got it

The thing about Kermit is, he's got a lot of power but he just isn't that good.
He went life and death with a few guys he should've handled and Margarito had his number, so the thing is he's not past prime, he is just what he is.
A flawed guy with some pop.

[Piper the Great]

jeff lacy - that joec beating took a toll on him.

[Guest]

jeff lacy - that joec beating took a toll on him.

Lacy was never that good either. He was just way overhyped from the get go.

[cbbulldog]

Im a Judah fan. He has hardly any discipline and it seems like he tries to do just enough to win, which susequently isn't usually enough.