POLL: Have Joe Calzaghe done enough to be considered an ATG (Top 100) ?

[Grand Champ]

Let the opinions role in.

[boxasmash]

this isn't even questionable.

of course he has.

[KESSLER]

lol, I'm sure we could fit him in Top 100.

[Fulcrum29]

probably not.

[Grand Champ]

this isn't even questionable.

of course he has.

It's a legitimate question. I'm not hating on Calzaghe, some people just wouldn't recognize fighting old hopkins and shot Jones to be enough to earn the place in the ATG.

[Grand Champ]

lol, I'm sure we could fit him in Top 100.

That would mean there would be no room for Mike Tyson who is ranked no 100.

[rizkybizness]

LMFAOOO

of course not

[KESSLER]

That would mean there would be no room for Mike Tyson who is ranked no 100.

Any list with Mike Tyson being rated only 100 is bull****.

[boxasmash]

It's a legitimate question. I'm not hating on Calzaghe, some people just wouldn't recognize fighting old hopkins and shot Jones to be enough to earn the place in the ATG.

if calzaghe was 2-0 and only fought those fighters then no.

funny enough calzaghe is 46-0, 20 years unbeaten, 21 title defences, two weight champion, undisputed champion @ smw, only fighter ever to hold two ring magazine titles at the same time aswell.

[Guest]

Of course.
He has over 20 title defenses. You have to be special to achieve those sorts of numbers.