ATTN Hatton fanboys: When Tarver beat Roy was he P4P 1?

[bsrizpac2]

No he wasn't. He did not become P4P 1.

Thanks for playing- I'll see you at the next nuthuggers convention.

[Left Hook Tua]

i'd rather have ricky #1 than calzaghe tbh.

best case scenario is if manny loses juanmanuel marquez gets the #1 spot.

if jmm loses to diaz...... i don't know......

i'd throw up if hopkins and calzaghe become #1 and 2.



i know they ain't gonna bump israel up.

can someone explain to me how a guy who whoops rafael marquez , jhonny gonzalez and oscar larios keeps moving DOWN on the p4p list?

so hopkins loses twice to taylor and once to calzaghe and he's no. 3 but rafael wins back to back fight of the years and he moves down?

this is bull****.

[bsrizpac2]

i'd rather have ricky #1 than calzaghe tbh.

best case scenario is if manny loses juanmanuel marquez gets the #1 spot.

if jmm loses to diaz...... i don't know......

i'd throw up if hopkins and calzaghe become #1 and 2.



i know they ain't gonna bump israel up.

can someone explain to me how a guy who whoops rafael marquez , jhonny gonzalez and oscar larios keeps moving DOWN on the p4p list?

so hopkins loses twice to taylor and once to calzaghe and he's no. 3 but rafael wins back to back fight of the years and he moves down?

this is bull****.

I don't care who is P4P1. I'm just asking the delusional hordes a simple question of logic. One that they will fail once again to grasp.

[Left Hook Tua]

I don't care who is P4P1. I'm just asking the delusional hordes a simple question of logic. One that they will fail once again to grasp.

hatton is not gonna get no. 1.

maybe if he was on the top 10 right now and then he beats pacquiao he'll get no. 1.

but......ricky is not ranked in the top 10 in most boxing sites (though he should be tbh)



if pacquaio losses who'd be your #1?

[Chups]

Roy Jones at number 1 when got beat by Tarver, Tarver gained the number 10 spot.

[bsrizpac2]

Roy Jones at number 1 when got beat by Tarver, Tarver gained the number 10 spot.

Exactly.....

[JoHnNyBoXeR]

if hatton wins calzaghe is number 1 by default.. hatton would be top 5 .. MAYBE top 3

[bsrizpac2]

hatton is not gonna get no. 1.

maybe if he was on the top 10 right now and then he beats pacquiao he'll get no. 1.

but......ricky is not ranked in the top 10 in most boxing sites (though he should be tbh)



if pacquaio losses who'd be your #1?

Most lists have Joe Calzaghe at 2. So he'd get bumped i suppose. I find those lists...hard to take seriously.

For me probably JMM since he basically ran with Pac so close and so recently. But I dunno, he hasn't shown as much since then tough to say. I do know it wouldn't be mother****in hatton.

[Left Hook Tua]

if hatton wins calzaghe is number 1 by default.. hatton would be top 5 .. MAYBE top 3

hatton should be top 5 right now.

[Left Hook Tua]

Most lists have Joe Calzaghe at 2. So he'd get bumped i suppose. I find those lists...hard to take seriously.

For me probably JMM since he basically ran with Pac so close and so recently. But I dunno, he hasn't shown as much since then tough to say. I do know it wouldn't be mother****in hatton.

yeah jmm should be #1.

he had a fight with pac the current #1 who could have gone either way and then he jumped to 135 and beat casa for the lineal belt.