Bernard Hopkins is Overrated....

[larryx]

roy beat bernard
so i guess
roy>bernard
sorry but its true

this isnt the point of my thread
but im just exposing your nu****** logic

i said resume

[circleinsidebox]

Lets just be clear Calzaghe's resume isn't better than Hopkins or RJJ just because he beat them

OK?

you mean you dont rank calzaghe higher than jones or b hop....
if ur saying that i agree

[circleinsidebox]

i said resume

but this thread
has nothing to do with resume

[hammerhiem]

you mean you dont rank calzaghe higher than jones or b hop....
if ur saying that i agree

I'm saying your logic fails.

[circleinsidebox]

I guess Glen Johnson, Antonio Tarver and Joe Calzaghe all should get full credit for defeating the great Roy Jones then. Not only did they beat him but they dominated him.

according to you folk, those wins don't matter
roy wasn't in his PRIME lol

[Ishy Aytan]

In your opinion who is a legend in this era, or in the last 20 years? What fighters would you describe as 'legends'?

[circleinsidebox]

I'm saying your logic fails.

you base greatness off of resumes
your opinions no longer are considered

[circleinsidebox]

In your opinion who is a legend in this era, or in the last 20 years? What fighters would you describe as 'legends'?

i would describe evander holyfield as a legend
also lennox lewis
mike tyson
manny pacquiao is on his way....

[TheGreatA]

according to you folk, those wins don't matter
roy wasn't in his PRIME lol

No according to anyone with common sense those wins do not matter as much as a win over PRIME Roy Jones.

Hopkins was clearly not the same fighter against Roy Jones in 1993 as he was later on in 2001. Neither was Jones against Johnson, Tarver and Calzaghe.

[hammerhiem]

you base greatness off of resumes
your opinions no longer are considered

Fair enough, if resume's are not the basis for you say is great your going to be called an idiot an awful lot.

I repeat resume's are the basis for deciding who is great, everything else is trimmings.

Otherwise Nassem Hamed is GOAT.