Does Erik Morales have higher quality wins then Trinidad?

[Tha_Greatest]

Pretty close call here.

Erik's 10 best victories in my opinion:

Barrera
Pacquiao
Ayala
Jones
Zaragoza
McCullough
Kelley
Chavez
Chi
Espadas

Trinidad's 10 best victories:

Vargas
Oscar
Carr
Reid
Campas
Whitaker
Joppy
Mayorga
Camacho
Pendleton

I could get into this subject, but I gotta eat.

Nobody even knows if Reid was ever any good, sure , he was a olympian but many plympian dont always become greats, David Reid has no quality wins i can think of. Joppy Mayorga Pendleton were exaggeringly overated ,OldGringo forgot to add Hernandes to the Morales list, which consist of no overated fighter at their weight class

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Clearly Tito

Mayorga
Joppy
Vargas
Thiam
Reid
DLH
Carr
Camacho
Whitaker
Barnes
Campas
Blocker

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Nobody even knows if Reid was ever any good, sure , he was a olympian but many plympian dont always become greats, David Reid has no quality wins i can think of. Joppy Mayorga Pendleton were exaggeringly overated ,OldGringo forgot to add Hernandes to the Morales list, which consist of no overated fighter at their weight class

And Kelley and Chavez are not exaggerating. And Zaragoza wasnt shot, and Pacquaio didnt beat the **** out him twice and made him quit!!!! STHU!!!!!!

[Steak]

No I concur. I think Barrera is one of the 5 or so greatest 122 pounders of all-time...and you could argue him being a top 10-15 Featherweight as well. Pacquiao has done nothing but impress since his early blunders. These two are all-timers. You couldn't really say that about anyone Trinidad faced, outside of Oscar (and that's a TOUGH argument), who didn't allow the fans to see a true conclusion in that fight. Vargas was an excellent fighter when Trinidad defeated him, but certainly one cannot say he was any more dangerous than Pacquiao was when Erik defeated him.

the thing with Trinidad is that while he doesnt have the huge, standout kind of wins that Morales had, he just beat so good many guys, and in devastating fashion a lot of the time too. lets see...Whitaker, Blocker, Pendleton, Oba Carr, Vargas, Campas, Reid, Joppy, Mayorga, Camacho...I cant remember anyone else. but man, these were fantastic wins. and most of these guys he really toasted.

even at Middleweight the guy was still looked at as almost impossible to beat.

[MANGLER]

Both guys have some good wins on their res. But Felix won his big fights by KO for the most part, so I'd call his more impressive.

[Tha_Greatest]

And Kelley and Chavez are not exaggerating. And Zaragoza wasnt shot, and Pacquaio didnt beat the **** out him twice and made him quit!!!! STHU!!!!!!

damn dude calm down, im just giving an opinion, i respect you but you sound angry as hell, i like blasting at people who get angry the way you are over a thread, the way you are, i dont want to start any war with you cause you are a good poster but just think of what im saying as a opinion, dont overwhelm yourself and get fanatical cause like i said , i actually respect your opinion, sorry if i offended you

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

damn dude calm down, im just giving an opinion, i respect you but you sound angry as hell, i like blasting at people who get angry the way you are over a thread, the way you are, i dont want to start any war with you cause you are a good poster but just think of what im saying as a opinion, dont overwhelm yourself and get fanatical cause like i said , i actually respect your opinion, sorry if i offended you

I thought you were going in the direction of discrediting Tito, wich is not the case. I dont like to discret wins for any fighter neither, but because I thought you were, thats why I said what I said. Any ways I apology if I sounded Fanatical or angry!!!!! But I see your point!!!!!!!!!

[Tha_Greatest]

I thought you were going in the direction of discrediting Tito, wich is not the case. I dont like to discret wins for any fighter neither, but because I thought you were, thats why I said what I said. Any ways I apology if I sounded Fanatical or angry!!!!! But I see your point!!!!!!!!!

tito is the greatest welterweight i have ever seen ,That I have ever seen, you get the picture, i dont even like Tito