Would We Even Be Talking About Joe Calzaghe?

[hookoutofhell]

which ever one would have lost ould have made an excuse about being weight drained and gone up to LHW.

imo JC would have won.

[S.G.]

Calzaghe is a very good fighter in his own right... he would get the respect he deserves one way or another even if he was to be dethroned at SMW by a prime Jones

for the record, i have Jones beating Calzaghe prime for prime, but Calzaghe putting up a great and exciting fight before maybe being KO'd/TKO'd later on

[Underdog82]

If Roy Jones Never left 168?

What if RJJ Stayed at 168 and just smashed joe in his prime, imo joe should thank roy for giving him a shot at his boxing career

You can't say A prime roy at 168 would get cut and beat up like he did in the calz fight?

its crazy man

thanx for reading my rant

[hammerhiem]

The question is would we be talking about Jones? I mean everyone agrees SMW was weak, he would have had the same problem come 2009 Calzaghe does, not enough world class names on his resume, simply because there isn't any world class SMW.

It's not like Hopkins was any more likely to fight RJJ than he was Calzaghe.

RJJ staying at SMW = not the legend and P4P All time top 50 fighter.

and yes I rank him higher than 50 take it as a number that signify's he's an ATG not a placement within that 50.

[S.G.]

The question is would we be talking about Jones? I mean everyone agrees SMW was weak, he would have had the same problem come 2009 Calzaghe does, not enough world class names on his resume, simply because there isn't any world class SMW.

It's not like Hopkins was any more likely to fight RJJ than he was Calzaghe.

RJJ staying at SMW = not the legend and P4P All time top 50 fighter.

and yes I rank him higher than 50 take it as a number that signify's he's an ATG not a placement within that 50.

yeah, without his overrated win over Ruiz Jones' resume falls apart

[Testdead]

If Roy Jones Never left 168?

What if RJJ Stayed at 168 and just smashed joe in his prime, imo joe should thank roy for giving him a shot at his boxing career

You can't say A prime roy at 168 would get cut and beat up like he did in the calz fight?

its crazy man

thanx for reading my rant

Roy aint smashing Calzaghe at any weight.

[bsrizpac]

If Roy Jones Never left 168?

What if RJJ Stayed at 168 and just smashed joe in his prime, imo joe should thank roy for giving him a shot at his boxing career

You can't say A prime roy at 168 would get cut and beat up like he did in the calz fight?

its crazy man

thanx for reading my rant

Do we talk about Thulani Maligna?

[Haglerwins]

Roy aint smashing Calzaghe at any weight.

SHOT Roy Jones put him down with ease. QUIET.

[hammerhiem]

yeah, without his overrated win over Ruiz Jones' resume falls apart

Thats not what i'm saying and you know it, but substitute his LHW run and his HW win with the Calzaghe's resume and would you say he would be talked about as P4P?

Unless you are a total hypocrite of course you wouldn't.

he become a 2 weight undefeated champ who has very few names on his resume same as Calzaghe.

[bsrizpac]

SHOT Roy Jones put him down with ease. QUIET.