Who's the better P4P #1 during their time? Pac or Floyd?

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

i like both but i'd have to say manny

[aether]

Their resumes are comparable but Manny does have losses while Floyd does not. It's too bad Floyd was too chicken to stick around though.

i've always believed that nobody knows for sure how good you are until you lose

[FasTHarD]

Their resumes are comparable but Manny does have losses while Floyd does not. It's too bad Floyd was too chicken to stick around though.

You dont have to be undefeated to become the p4p king or to make p4p top 10... JLC got many loss before he become at p4p top 10... Mayweather is undefeated cuz he ducked his comp....

[Mayfeather]

This is a very hard question to answer. I mean Pac has done a lot more recently but then you can't knock either of the two fighters opponents. The no losses certainly backs up Mayweathers case but then the fact that Pac has had a crazy year helps him out. Its too hard to call imo

[Del Coqui]

American publicists have picked Floyd for the past few years knowing lately his opposition was ****, Pac fought the better opposition, took on bigger challenges, true boxing fans know who the real p4p been all along.

[badboypeenoy]

Their resumes are comparable but Manny does have losses while Floyd does not. It's too bad Floyd was too chicken to stick around though.

That clown is unbeaten because he's chicken. Guzman and Calzaghe are unbeaten as well and Calzaghe can even argue that his resume is better than Floyd, only difference is that Floyd's American so his being "unbeaten" is given that much weight.

He is a coward, and his fighting style is cowardly, he serves boxing best retired.

[Mayfeather]

I dont see how u can't see that Mayweather was awesome though?

[badboypeenoy]

I dont see how u can't see that Mayweather was awesome though?

He's got the skills to be great, but he's got the balls of a wimp, how's that awesome?

[Mayfeather]

He may have the balls of a wimp in your opinion but his boxing skills are awesome. You said earlier he serves boxing better retired, and I don't know how you can justify that?

[badboypeenoy]

He may have the balls of a wimp in your opinion but his boxing skills are awesome. You said earlier he serves boxing better retired, and I don't know how you can justify that?

Last thing boxing needs right now is another Mayweather vs. Baldomir or a Mayweather vs. dela Hoya. Those are fights guaranteed to make casual fans turn to MMA.

Awesome skills not used awesomely, awesomely stinks.