Who's the better P4P #1 during their time? Pac or Floyd?

[Vasyl’s dad]

Floyd P4P #1 Reign: 3 years (2005,2006,2007)

Pacquaio P4P #1 reign :1 year


Pacquaio has to hold the title alot longer before we even have this conversation..

Pac in 1 year, proved more than Mayweather did in 3.

[Horus]

Pac in 1 year, proved more than Mayweather did in 3.

you sound ******

[Vasyl’s dad]

you sound ******

Dude won 3 fights in 3 weight classes in the span of 1 calendar year.

He beat better opponents, in more devasting fashion in less time.

Lets take a look at Floyds 2005
Mitchell
Gatti
Brusseles

2006
Judah
Baldomir

2007
DLH
Hatton


Like I said, Mannys 1 year>>>>Floyds 3.

[-Lowkey-]

pac for me and its not even that close hes took more risks fought better comp seems that he will fight anyone put in front of him hes a much more exciting p4p no1 than floyd could ever have been

and who gives a **** about how long floyd was p4p no1 tell me in those 3 years who did he fight that had a realistic shot at beating him?

[aether]

Corrales and Castillo are as good as Morales and Barrera, Floyd just ruined them. If you think Pac has the skills of Floyd you're crazy. I love Pac but Hatton will kill him. Gatti's a ***

that's just sad

[badboypeenoy]

you can call Floyd gay all you want, but he has beat better fighters...simple as that

Like who? Gatti?

[aether]

Corrales and Castillo are as good as Morales and Barrera, Floyd just ruined them. If you think Pac has the skills of Floyd you're crazy. I love Pac but Hatton will kill him. Gatti's a ***

aww god. come on. i aint ****ting you but how on god's green earth is corrales and castillo as great as morales and barrera? please explain. im ready to be proven wrong

[FasTHarD]

Pacquiao easy.. When Floyd was the p4p king there's a lot of arguement about who's the really p4p in the world cuz Pac got better resume than Floyd at that time... When Pac become p4p no where near or no arguement on him and his resume...

[FasTHarD]

Pac in 1 year, proved more than Mayweather did in 3.

Green K on you.. You beat me to it...

[5burowz]

Their resumes are comparable but Manny does have losses while Floyd does not. It's too bad Floyd was too chicken to stick around though.