Are Castillo and Corrales all-time greats?

[TheGreatA]

So I said Duran beat Ray Leonard, an all-time great in his prime, something Mayweather never accomplished.

This is the response I got:

diego corrales, jose luis castillo are atg and were in their prime. so please try harder you're making this too easy

What is your opinion?

[savorduhflavor]

Of course not.

They were good, solid wins for Floyd though.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

**** no!!!!!!!! Of course brandish is going to say that, he needs to jusify Mayweathers resume with something!!!!!!!

[Savino]

The 10th round of the first fight was an all great round and that is about it.

[RAESAAD]

No neither will go down as alltime greats but they will defintely be remember for an alltime great fight.....both should be HOF though IMO....just not remembered as ATG.

[El Dominicano]

Brandish seems to think so.

As much as I'd wish they were. Gonna have to say no...but they were GREAT wins for Floyd

I mean Chico wasn't gonna find any sucess fighting at 147...when he clearly would have dominated at 135...JLC had weight problems and got hit way too many times

These 2 might have messed up eachother...when they faught

[badboypeenoy]

Nope, but they were more exciting fighters than Mayweather can ever hope to be.

[MANGLER]

Every word that comes outta Brandish's mouth has PBF's jizz all over it. Don't sweat his opinions.

[Clegg]

Every word that comes outta Brandish's mouth has PBF's jizz all over it. Don't sweat his opinions.

Ha ha yeah I agree.

Mangler, I noticed that you don't nuthug anyone, and you don't hate anyone, or at least you don't get biased. Who is your favourite boxer out of everyone out there right now?

[TheGreatA]

As much as I'd wish they were. Gonna have to say no...but they were GREAT wins for Floyd

I mean Chico wasn't gonna find any sucess fighting at 147...when he clearly would have dominated at 135...JLC had weight problems and got hit way too many times

These 2 might have messed up eachother...when they faught

I thought they were both great to watch, especially against each other, and I do not want to disrespect either fighter. It was only a response to Brandish saying Mayweather accomplished something Duran didn't by winning a couple of more alphabet belts.

The opposition you beat is what matters.