Are Castillo and Corrales all-time greats?

[FasTHarD]

So I said Duran beat Ray Leonard, an all-time great in his prime, something Mayweather never accomplished.

This is the response I got:



What is your opinion?

Nooooooooooooooooooooooo..................

[El Dominicano]

I thought they were both great to watch, especially against each other, and I do not want to disrespect either fighter. It was only a response to Brandish saying Mayweather accomplished something Duran didn't by winning a couple of more alphabet belts.

The opposition you beat is what matters.

I agree...I'd like to see Mayweather at 160-168...maybe they'll understand. I mean would Floyd have been able to beat a say Wilfred Benitez...Does Floyd have a name on his resume better then Carlos Palomino

The disrespect Duran is gettin don't make sense to me either. Most Floyd fans brag about how Floyd is a 5 division champion...You atleast gotta respect the fact that Duran and Floyd are the same size and Duran kicked ass in higher weight divisions then Floyd

[Bushbaby]

Not individually,but together they provided the best fight maybe of any era in boxing,and will never be forgotten!!

[Tha_Greatest]

hall of famers yes, A graded quality fighters in their true divisions, yes, but not all time greats, great fighters who basically underachieved

[Silencers]

No, they aren't. At best they're HOFers.

[larryx]

hof's hell yea..atg=no

[wmute]

So I said Duran beat Ray Leonard, an all-time great in his prime, something Mayweather never accomplished.

This is the response I got:



What is your opinion?

Of course not.

Hehe I am kind of glad to see you go out of your way to set some bull**** straight... I was jealous of your ability to be impassible while reading bull**** replies to sensible observations.

[Zocalo]

No... they aren't.

[mr. bojangles]

No, they aren't. At best they're HOFers.

spot on, mate..

[Jim Jeffries]

1.Sugar Ray Robinson
2.Henry Armstrong
3.Muhammad Ali
4.Sugar Ray Leoanrd
5.Roy JOnes Jr
6.Floyd Mayweather Jr
7.Marvin Hagler
8.Bernard Hopkins
9.Pernell Whitaker
10.Joe Louis
11. James Toney
12. Larry Homes
13. Lennox Lewis
14. Tommy Hearns
15. Evander Holyfield
16. Aaron Pryor
17. Alexis Arguello
18. Julio Caesar chavez
19. Ricardo Lopez
20. Jack Johnson
21. Mike Tyson
22. benny leoanrd
23. willie pep
24. George Foreman
25. Archie Moore
26. Ezzard Charles
27. Bob Foster
28. Carlos Monzon
29. Harry Greb
30. sandy sadler
31. Roberto Duran
32. Felix Trinidad
33. Kid gavlan

There's something a bit different about Brandish's top 16 ATGs, but I just can't quite put my finger on it. He then said he'd never seen or studied Pep, but somehow managed to squeeze him in at 23. He says stuff like "Kostya Tszyu isn't on Hatton's level," "Mayweather ruled 130 for 6 years," "Iran Barkley was a bum," and "Duran should've fought Roy Jones, Michael Nunn and Hopkins."

Duran isn't a top 10 ATG (arguable,) but Mayweather is #6? GTFOOH.

And no, these two are very good fighters, but not ATGs. I'll be surprised to see either make the HOF TBH.