If Mayweather returns, who's the number 1 P4P king?

[S.G.]

Mayweather would have to earn it back

[bootleggking]

Why the hell would anything change unless Pac gets beat?

did u read my post? does pac really deserve the number 1 spot? Cotto was number two and margarito knocked him out and calzaghe was behind him (in most p4p lists) and he beat jones (which was badly faded just like de la hoya) and JMM was usually ranked one slot behind Pacquiao and he beat Casamayor who came off a huge win over katsidis? So who fought the highest caliber of opponent out of these guys?

[Chr0nic]

did u read my post? does pac really deserve the number 1 spot? Cotto was number two and margarito knocked him out and calzaghe was behind him (in most p4p lists) and he beat jones (which was badly faded just like de la hoya) and JMM was usually ranked one slot behind Pacquiao and he beat Casamayor who came off a huge win over katsidis? So who fought the highest caliber of opponent out of these guys?

yes, yes he does

[bootleggking]

Pac was #1 p4p way before his win over DLH. PBF passed that moniker on to Pac when he quit. And at this point, Pac's takin on all comers>PBF's dodgin WW challengers and he likely woulda surpassed him anyway.

but before cotto lost to margarito he was number 2... No doubt about that! so why wasn't margarito made number 2 or 1 after that?

[bootleggking]

yes, yes he does

answer the rest the questions also

[bootleggking]

pac was #1 p4p before he koed delahoya... and and mayweather shouldnt even be ranked because he retired from the sport. maybe you can rank his legacy to all the other retired boxers.

i know he's retired but the question is if he returns

[_Hunter_]

Joe Calzaghe will be number 1.

[MANGLER]

did u read my post? does pac really deserve the number 1 spot? Cotto was number two and margarito knocked him out and calzaghe was behind him (in most p4p lists) and he beat jones (which was badly faded just like de la hoya) and JMM was usually ranked one slot behind Pacquiao and he beat Casamayor who came off a huge win over katsidis? So who fought the highest caliber of opponent out of these guys?

Who the hell had Cotto ranked #2 p4p at any point? He was never up that high, thus Marg didn't climb that high when he beat him. JMM's win over Casa vaulted him past Joe C, and was more impressive than Joe's win over Jones so he stayed there. And all this was happenin while PBF was retired. So how does Pac not deserve the #1 spot homey?

[bootleggking]

Who the hell had Cotto ranked #2 p4p at any point? He was never up that high, thus Marg didn't climb that high when he beat him. JMM's win over Casa vaulted him past Joe C, and was more impressive than Joe's win over Jones so he stayed there. And all this was happenin while PBF was retired. So how does Pac not deserve the #1 spot homey?

dude... cotto was considered number 2 on most p4p lists... u have to remember that there is no "official" p4p list.. but on 8 out of 10 cotto was always number two after he beat mosley... don't try to flip it.. and answer the question... who fought the better oppenent since mayweather retired?

[Chr0nic]

answer the rest the questions also

cotto was like 3rd was'nt he? and just look at manny's record, and he was number 1 before fighting de la hoya, if i remember correctly