Joe Calzaghe is P4P #1

[THE REED]

so you think calzaghe would lost to all the top 5 american fighters 10 years ago

It has nothing to do with where there from.... if Roy was a black australian, it would be the same outcome.

[dde91]

so you think calzaghe would lost to all the top 5 american fighters 10 years ago

Not all, but he wouldn't be Undefeated. He got knocked down by HOpkins and JOnes when they were Way past their primes. THink on them in their prime.

[Left Hook Tua]

ATG like:



Omar Sheika
David Starie
Rick Thornberry

Branko Sobot
Luciano Torres
Tyler Hughes
Carlos Christie

hey! take sheika off that list!

omar was good. my favorite fighter at 168 after benn was gone......

[mitch12]

"fighted"

Joe doesnt beat 1998 Roy, just... no.

Joe doesnt beat 1998 Bernard, just... no.

Joe - Toney could be close... id give the edge to Toney.

And Tarver? in 1998?

i understand you say jones beats calzaghe then even i do but comon back then calzaghe hit quite hard compared to now surely he could beat toney or hopkins then if he tried hard enough or could gone either way in both of them fights .

[mitch12]

Not all, but he wouldn't be Undefeated. He got knocked down by HOpkins and JOnes when they were Way past their primes. THink on them in their prime.

but they still have power jones still hits hard even now.

[THE REED]

i understand you say jones beats calzaghe then even i do but comon back then calzaghe hit quite hard compared to now surely he could beat toney or hopkins then if he tried hard enough or could gone either way in both of them fights .

"if he tried hard enough..."

Joe got a split decision over Bernard when he was 43 years old...

Have you ever seen prime Toney at 168?

[THE REED]

but they still have power jones still hits hard even now.

But they both lacked the stamina at there age to follow up with that power... 10 years ago... Bernard and ROy could have both closed the show

[mitch12]

But they both lacked the stamina at there age to follow up with that power... 10 years ago... Bernard and ROy could have both closed the show

well surley you agree they would be good of been good fights

[THE REED]

well surley you agree they would be good of been good fights

of course i would agree with that... Im not calling Joe a bum... but your matching him up with absolute elite competition... and I believe 10 years ago, the fighters you mentioned were just too skilled

[Wales08]

Not all, but he wouldn't be Undefeated. He got knocked down by HOpkins and JOnes when they were Way past their primes. THink on them in their prime.

People ned to start to think that Joe is not in his prime and is actually far from it.

Prime this prime that......