Boxingscene's P4P list has Paul Williams 8th on the list where

[ferocity]

Just went over the p4p list and i didn't even see Vics name, what a joke. Even Pavlik who never lost in his weight divison, or Abrahem for that matter. I could name more guys yet, Williams is in the p4p list over these guys lol.

[egreezy]

so he moved up in weight and has fought nobody. pavlik atleast lost to the number # 4 p4p. hatton lost to #1 p4p. william lost to someone that will never be in the p4p list

#2 rank JMW is nobody? and the #1 ranked Forrest said he don't want it.

He beat Margarito when Margarito was very hated and when Margs wasn't the man. Even after Wililams long reign he finally lost to Quintanna. He avenged it but now trilogy what a joke. But Quintanna is after his ass so it'll happen.

Take the Margarito win away and what makes him a p4p fighter? Williams getting to much credit so early, its makes the p4p list look like a joke.

So ppl can discredit Williams win over Margarito by saying he wasn't the man. But say Floyd should have fought him when he wasn't the man? Take Cotto win away from Marg is he on anybody p4p list?

[crold1]

Just went over the p4p list and i didn't even see Vics name, what a joke. Even Pavlik who never lost in his weight divison, or Abrahem for that matter. I could name more guys yet, Williams is in the p4p list over these guys lol.

Read again...it's all in the #10 spot in the Dawson take.

[ferocity]

#2 rank JMW is nobody? and the #1 ranked Forrest said he don't want it.

So ppl can discredit Williams win over Margarito by saying he wasn't the man. But say Floyd should have fought him when he wasn't the man? Take Cotto win away from Marg is he on anybody p4p list?

Based on the reason why williams is on the list then yes. But if it was up to me no.

[ferocity]

Read again...it's all in the #10 spot in the Dawson take.

I guess you havn't heard how Vic wants the rematch. And what Vic did to Mijares is bigger then what Nonito did to Vic. Cause Vic fought a bigger fighter in Mijares. Where as Nonito came down in wait to fight the lighter champion.

Williams over Vic is a joke.

Even then you hold it against Vic for not rematching Nonito, but you dont' hold it against Williams for not pursuing a match with Clottey or a trilogy with Quintanna.

Williams should not be there at least not yet.

Abrahem hasn't even lost and yet Williams get more love lol, thats a joke.

[egreezy]

I guess you havn't heard how Vic wants the rematch. And what Vic did to Mijares is bigger then what Nonito did to Vic. Cause Vic fought a bigger fighter in Mijares. Where as Nonito came down in wait to fight the lighter champion.

Williams over Vic is a joke.

Even then you hold it against Vic for not rematching Nonito, but you dont' hold it against Williams for not pursuing a match with Clottey or a trilogy with Quintanna.

Williams should not be there at least not yet.

Abrahem hasn't even lost and yet Williams get more love lol, thats a joke.

your reaching with Abraham... now its its a little too obvious

[ferocity]

your reaching with Abraham... now its its a little too obvious

Let me guess.

White guys can't fight.

That was the mind set of the 90's, brah.

[crold1]

your reaching with Abraham... now its its a little too obvious

No he's not. AA may have been the best Middle in the world two years ago. He's a VERY good fighter.

[egreezy]

Let me guess.

White guys can't fight.

That was the mind set of the 90's, brah.

I was talking resume not talent...notice I did not mention Vic when I said you reaching. He has to beat Sturm or Pavlik to get near top10.

[ferocity]

I was talking resume not talent...notice I did not mention Vic when I said you reaching. He has to beat Sturm or Pavlik to get near top10.

Explain then why Williams is in the p4p list? He don't deserve it yet.