Boxingscene's P4P list has Paul Williams 8th on the list where

[egreezy]

With reason after taking a beating. Still that doesn't give Chad or Paul the right to ride on top of him. How about Hatton?

What did Taylor do after he got KO'd immediate rematch. Cotto lost to Marg, Williams did not...Cotto was also his mandatory did not take fight until he vacated and Jennings was opponent.

[$partacus]

Hopkins ahead of JMM too, The Rings list is a much better one

[Hagler★]

Cotto beat Quintana, SSM, Paulie, Ricardo Torres, Zab and had a competitive fight with Margarito. I don't see why he shouldn't be on the list...and if you look at Cotto's resume...He beat undefeated fighters with really good records although they were no names. Still that is no way to come up into boxing

Cotto deserves to be on it more then Chad also not just Paul

its true all of a sudden after losing a ver competitive fight with Margarito he has been written off

[egreezy]

and look at my thread the fighters who received the most votes.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=227712

[Ray*]

ok last 5 fights for dawson.

Adamek-light heavy champ
ruiz-bum
mendoza-glorified bum who almost beat the great lacy(one of calzaghes best wins)
glen johnson-very good fighter and former champ who knocked jones out cold before calzaghe chose to fight him for money
tarver-light heavy champ who has beaten jones, johnson, and woods


lets look at hatton

malignaggi-no notable wins on his resume but has a big mouth
lazcano-decent contender at lightweight 5 years ago!
Mayweather-well yea we know what happened
castillo-totally shot lightweight moving up
urango-no notable wins and is slow as carl froch

not to mention dawson didn't get ktfo and is way more skilled than hatton you have a point.

lmaooooooo

[$partacus]

and look at my thread the fighters who received the most votes.
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=227712

No option to vote for None of them? that poll means nothing without that option

[El Dominicano]

its true all of a sudden after losing a ver competitive fight with Margarito he has been written off

Like I said a lose can do wonders

[crold1]

its true all of a sudden after losing a ver competitive fight with Margarito he has been written off

Not being considered one of the ten best fighters across 17 weight divisions, which with lineal champs and borderline contenders makes up approx. 200 fighters who could be rated somewhere, is not being written off. THis sort of statement reflects how overblown P4P debates can become. Most would still rate Cotto #2 at welter since P-Will is moved up. That's the rating which matters.

[Hagler★]

Not being considered one of the ten best fighters across 17 weight divisions, which with lineal champs and borderline contenders makes up approx. 200 fighters who could be rated somewhere, is not being written off. THis sort of statement reflects how overblown P4P debates can become. Most would still rate Cotto #2 at welter since P-Will is moved up. That's the rating which matters.

i meant in general not just because he isnt top 10 .especially on here a lot of people have written him off, his performance that night would have beaten many if not most and Margarito is a freak of nature in that he absorbs so much damage but keeps coming but Cotto is hardly credited for his performance because he lost

[crold1]

i meant in general not just because he isnt top 10 .especially on here a lot of people have written him off, his performance that night would have beaten many if not most and Margarito is a freak of nature in that he absorbs so much damage but keeps coming but Cotto is hardly credited for his performance because he lost

Anyone who has written off Cotto for one loss is nuts. He may not ever be Marg but time will tell if there a ton of other guys he can beat. It's just a loss.