Boxingscene's P4P list has Paul Williams 8th on the list where

**hammerhiem** · 12-08-2008, 04:36 AM

I see nothing wrong with this, I also don't have Cotto in my top ten.

**SHB** · 12-08-2008, 04:38 AM

Originally posted by El Dominicano

Cotto is no where to be found. I gotta say that is wrong yet funny

Why? Williams > Cotto. Is that really open to discussion?

**El Dominicano** · 12-08-2008, 04:40 AM

Originally posted by hammerhiem

I see nothing wrong with this, I also don't have Cotto in my top ten.

Cotto beat Quintana, SSM, Paulie, Ricardo Torres, Zab and had a competitive fight with Margarito. I don't see why he shouldn't be on the list...and if you look at Cotto's resume...He beat undefeated fighters with really good records although they were no names. Still that is no way to come up into boxing

Cotto deserves to be on it more then Chad also not just Paul

**hammerhiem** · 12-08-2008, 04:43 AM

The only objection to that list is Dawson at 10, and Yet HAtton who beat the No2 in the division badly doesn't even get a look in even on the might be in there list.

Compair Dawsons last 5 figths to Hattons and tell me he deserves to be above him... I think not!

**TheGreatA** · 12-08-2008, 04:43 AM

One loss in boxing and you're a nobody it seems.

I'm sure Cotto will be back in people's p4p lists after he looks impressive in his next fight, even if it's against Michael Jennings.

**El Dominicano** · 12-08-2008, 04:45 AM

Originally posted by TheManchine

One loss in boxing and you're a nobody it seems.

I'm sure Cotto will be back in people's p4p lists after he looks impressive in his next fight, even if it's against Michael Jennings.

Cotto has an underated resume. I still got him on my Top 10...Hatton should also be on it. I agree ONE lose could do serious damage

**egreezy** · 12-08-2008, 04:50 AM

Cotto did not do enough this year

**El Dominicano** · 12-08-2008, 04:55 AM

Originally posted by egreezy

Cotto did not do enough this year

With reason after taking a beating. Still that doesn't give Chad or Paul the right to ride on top of him. How about Hatton?

**daggum** · 12-08-2008, 04:55 AM

Originally posted by hammerhiem

The only objection to that list is Dawson at 10, and Yet HAtton who beat the No2 in the division badly doesn't even get a look in even on the might be in there list.

Compair Dawsons last 5 figths to Hattons and tell me he deserves to be above him... I think not!

ok last 5 fights for dawson.

adamek-light heavy champ
ruiz-bum
mendoza-glorified bum who almost beat the great lacy(one of calzaghes best wins)
glen johnson-very good fighter and former champ who knocked jones out cold before calzaghe chose to fight him for money
tarver-light heavy champ who has beaten jones, johnson, and woods

lets look at hatton

malignaggi-no notable wins on his resume but has a big mouth
lazcano-decent contender at lightweight 5 years ago!
mayweather-well yea we know what happened
castillo-totally shot lightweight moving up
urango-no notable wins and is slow as carl froch

not to mention dawson didn't get ktfo and is way more skilled than hatton you have a point.

Boxingscene's P4P list has Paul Williams 8th on the list where