Better Resume out of these 6

[S.G.]

1. Hopkins
2. Pacquiao
3. Toney
4. Mayweather
5. Calzaghe
6. Jones Jr.

(bottom 3 are interchangeable)

[FloydsEra]

Mayweather doesn't need a great resume(even though he has one). Any true famn of boxing can watch him fight and determine he's an ATG

[Poet682006]

Clearly Toney but he DID lose to a number of those big names on his resume.
Three fights against Mike McCallum is head and shoulders above anything the others have to offer.

Poet

[C.Y.]

B-Hop> RJJ> James Toney> Mayweather> Pacman> Calzaghe

I think that is about right

Now how would everyone else have it.

bhop>mayweather>jones>pacman>toney>calzaghe

[hammerhiem]

Mayweather doesn't need a great resume(even though he has one). Any true famn of boxing can watch him fight and determine he's an ATG

If we are talking skill level my order would be much different.

[xcaret]

resume:

rjj>pac>toney>money>bhop>cal

skills:

rjj>money>toney>pac>bhop>cal

how does pac have more skills then bhop or cal?

[FloydsEra]

If we are talking skill level my order would be much different.

don't mind me I'm loaded. I will log off now

[El Dominicano]

1. Hopkins
2. Pacquiao
3. Toney
4. Mayweather
5. Calzaghe
6. Jones Jr.

Wai wait stop right there...

Your saying everyone on that list has a better resume then RJJ?

You can debate Mayweather has a better 130 resume then Pacman and Pacman did most of his work at 130...Mayweather went on to do thingz 135,140,147,154...C'mon

Be Serious

Unless your jokin

[C.Y.]

Clearly Toney but he DID lose to a number of those big names on his resume.
Three fights against Mike McCallum is head and shoulders above anything the others have to offer.

Poet

sorry i have to disagree with that statement

[S.G.]

people mistake skills and physical attributes a lot