Calzaghe's win over Roy JONES Means nothing

[dino]

Who did Roy beat to be considered a revelant 175 pounder? He decisioned Anthony Hanshaw who was later KNOCKED OUT by Andre Dirrelll (a guy who's never been in the ring with a champion yet), he beat Felix Trinidad who's best weight is 147 and 154. Hopkins is ancient, and doesn't fight the same as he use too.

If Calzaghe wasn't P4P number 1 or a legend prior to these 2 last fights then he's still not, because he beat 2 old me, and barely beat the first 1

[hammerhiem]

Tell that to Calzaghe's bank manager.

[evilp0ptart]

I kind of agree, though I'm more on the side of Roy was too old to be considered a serious challenge....

It's "relevant" btw....

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Who did Roy beat to be considered a revelant 175 pounder? He decisioned Anthony Hanshaw who was later KNOCKED OUT by Andre Dirrelll (a guy who's never been in the ring with a champion yet), he beat Felix Trinidad who's best weight is 147 and 154. Hopkins is ancient, and doesn't fight the same as he use too.

If Calzaghe wasn't P4P number 1 or a legend prior to these 2 last fights then he's still not, because he beat 2 old me, and barely beat the first 1

Legacy wise it was a big victory. Having RJJ in your resume is not bad. And he beat Hopkins clearly close but Clearly!!!!!!

[WLAD_OWNS]

Go get some liposuction you fat drunken slob!!!

[hammerhiem]

Can we agree than that if Cal beating Jones means nothing then Dawson beating older and never as good Tarver and Johnson means even less?

[bobbito]

you can make an argument just based off of the fact he cleaned out the 168 lb division...175 is just for kicks...beating hopkins and jones doesnt hurt either...

[dino]

I want to see Calzaghe beat young, up and comers like Chad Dawson, and yes Tarver and Johnson are revelant *******, their both top 175 pounders, no matter their age, Roy Jones is not anymore

[them_apples]

Can we agree than that if Cal beating Jones means nothing then Dawson beating older and never as good Tarver and Johnson means even less?

except Tarver could pull the trigger, Tarver was definently past it to, but Jones has been Koed, has no legs left and can't pull the trigger...definition of shot.

[TheManchine]

Go get some liposuction you fat drunken slob!!!

Dino, get off the sofa, put down the beer and hit the treadmill you hillbilly