Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time?

[pesticid]

Zaghe's got the best defense of a pressure fighter with his hands down period. There is never been a pressure fighter fighting with the hands on his hips and getting hit as little as Joe did.

[YUHHHHHHH!]

no, he didnt. 51-0. you lose. which doesnt make him near the best ever, but hey, you brought up these statistics in the first place...

Ricardo Lopez had a draw. That's not a perfect record, if we're doing this statistic-wise.

[shynequasiog22]

The thread starter is an idiot for even asking. Top 100 maybe even top 75, but thats as far as i'll go. There is an argument for higher but to even suggest he is top 10 is idiotic.

[Calzaghe - 50-0]

Ricardo Lopez? sigh.

I summon daggum to attack the rest of your post.

Ricardo Lopez doesn't have a perfect record thats where he's different from Marciano and Calzaghe.

[Wiley Hyena]

Ricardo Lopez had a draw. That's not a perfect record, if we're doing this statistic-wise.

AND we are....on the pro side of the debate..... Sorry Blackirish..you lose.

[Steak]

Ricardo Lopez had a draw. That's not a perfect record, if we're doing this statistic-wise.

so a draw is a bad thing? interesting.

I always thought that a perfect record=no losses. I guess if you have a NC or ND then you dont have a perfect record either.

[fightnews55]

If you mean greatest fraud of all time then yes.

[Dan...]

Irish, explain to me why you are trying to engage in a rational debate with guys who see it as logical to place Cazlaghe alongside the likes of Duran, Leonard and Hagler and above the likes of Hearns and Jones in terms of all time status.

[Wiley Hyena]

If you mean greatest fraud of all time then yes.

No....we're not talking about Mayweather here. Leave him out of it. He doesn't belong in the discussion.

[El Dominicano]

Irish, explain to me why you are trying to engage in a rational debate with guys who see it as logical to place Cazlaghe alongside the likes of Duran, Leonard and Hagler and above the likes of Hearns and Jones in terms of all time status.

I agree...No need to listen to these fools