Is Calzaghe P4P#1? What's your P4P top 10 list?

[PoetryInMotion]

1.Manny Pacqiao
2.Juan Marquez
3.Joe Calzaghe
4.Bernard Hopkins
5.Israel Vasquez
6.Antonio Margarito
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Rafael Marquez
9.Ivan Calderon
10.Paul Williams

In terms of what they have done recently, but in actual boxing skills(what is the sweet science) at the time I got..

1.Juan Marquez
2.Bernard Hopkins
3.Miguel Cotto
4.Ivan Calderon
5.Rafael Marquez

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I struggle to disagree with this, but I'm not sure either way. I do think p4p rankings are seeing some odd jumps, sometimes it's justified others not. Cotto was too high before, and Margarito too high now, plus it's ridiculous he's super champ or whatever for some special reason unknown.

I know most see the welterweight as the strongest division and have done for a wee while, but I think the top guys get a little too much cred, sometimes in the p4p rankings too. To have Cotto, Margarito and Williams in the top 10 seems excessive when you consider there's what 12 divisions to choose from. Imagine if Mayweather came back. That's nearly 50% of the p4p rankings as the welterweight division, seems ridiculous.

I was jus trying to make a point. But I do agree with you.

[Kris Silver]

I was jus trying to make a point. But I do agree with you.

LOL, I know, and I was agreeing with you.

[Ryn0]

1. Pacquiao
2. Calzaghe
3. Hopkins
4. Marquez
5. Vazquez
6. Margarito
7. Williams
8. Dawson
9. Calderon
10. Cotto

[xxjace]

Jones was not even ranked..The only thing Jones did for Calzaghe was a win on joe's resume over an old jones..( Wow Impressive)

[!! Mr. Soprano]

When Margarito beat Cotto. Cotto was # 3 in most lists. and margarito was not near the top 15. thats Why, Cotto should be higher. Is like if DLh beats Pacman, and you put Pacman at # 5 and Oscar at #3

Perhaps I'm looking at the whole P4P the wrong way... but in my interpretation, the P4P means who would win if all fighters were in the same weight class (and more or less the same size)
and not really just on past performance / resume alone.

That's why for example, if Pacuiao and Calzaghe were lets' say both Middleweights.. I see Calzaghe beating him.

Margarito beat Cotto, so why would Cotto be higher than him in the rankings...


But hey, that's just one way of looking at things

[Pride Of Arkans]

Jones was not even ranked..The only thing Jones did for Calzaghe was a win on joe's resume over an old jones..( Wow Impressive)

Yeah but the ****head in your avatar and sig was the champ
and number one at the weight before Joe bullied him
and thats why Calzaghe's number 1.

[Flawless 2]

Pacman
JMM
Calzaghe
Hopkins
Paul Williams

[El Dominicano]

1. Pacman
2. Calzaghe
3. B-Hop
4. JMM
5. Margarito
6. Cotto
7. Pavlik
8. Izzy
9. Calderon
10. Darchinyan