Is Calzaghe P4P#1? What's your P4P top 10 list?

[MELLY-MEL...]

He is a damn powerful MW for a small guy... solid chin...
As of now, I don't think Pavlik beats him.

fair enough, but he has no wins that get him even close to the top 10 imo, but to each his own my man.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Very good list... with some Puerto Rican bias

Well yeah maybe I went to high with Calderon. But Cotto is still better than Margarito.

[Dan...]

Putting AA in the top 10 p4p right now is absurd. A win over Edison gets you on the list now? FFS, i might give it a crack.

[shynequasiog22]

1. Pacman
2. Marquez
3. Calzaghe
4. Hopkins
5. Vazquez
6. P. Williams
7. R. Marquez
8. Cotto
9. Calderon
10. Margarito

Am I the only one who thinks there is a serious drop off after the top 5. The rest can really be put in any order until somebody really steps up and separates themselves.

[T-97]

1 calzaghe
2 calzaghe
3 calzaghe
4 calzaghe
5 calzaghe
6 calzaghe
7 calzaghe
8 calzaghe
9 calzaghe
10 calzaghe

Your attempt at Calzaghe sarcasm would be funny, but it's really not.

[egreezy]

Juan Marquez
Manny Pacquia
Joe Calzaghe
Bernard Hopkins
Rafael Marquez
Israel Vasquez
Ivan Calderon
Paul Williams
Chad Dawson
Antonio Margarito
_Next 5_________
Nonito Donaire
Vic Darchinyan
Miguel Cotto
Kelly Pavlik
Nate Campbell

[larryx]

Your attempt at Calzaghe sarcasm would be funny, but it's really not.

damned if i do damned if i dont...

[!! Mr. Soprano]

fair enough, but he has no wins that get him even close to the top 10 imo, but to each his own my man.

I don't disagree with you

Well yeah maybe I went to high with Calderon. But Cotto is still better than Margarito.

How so? Didn't he knock him out?
But I would still keep him in the top 10... I had him at #3-4 before he lost to Margarito

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I don't disagree with you



How so? Didn't he knock him out?
But I would still keep him in the top 10... I had him at #3-4 before he lost to Margarito

When Margarito beat Cotto. Cotto was # 3 in most lists. and margarito was not near the top 15. thats Why, Cotto should be higher. Is like if DLh beats Pacman, and you put Pacman at # 5 and Oscar at #3

[Kris Silver]

When Margarito beat Cotto. Cotto was # 3 in most lists. and margarito was not near the top 15. thats Why, Cotto should be higher. Is like if DLh beats Pacman, and you put Pacman at # 5 and Oscar at #3

I struggle to disagree with this, but I'm not sure either way. I do think p4p rankings are seeing some odd jumps, sometimes it's justified others not. Cotto was too high before, and Margarito too high now, plus it's ridiculous he's super champ or whatever for some special reason unknown.

I know most see the welterweight as the strongest division and have done for a wee while, but I think the top guys get a little too much cred, sometimes in the p4p rankings too. To have Cotto, Margarito and Williams in the top 10 seems excessive when you consider there's what 12 divisions to choose from. Imagine if Mayweather came back. That's nearly 50% of the p4p rankings as the welterweight division, seems ridiculous.