Is Calzaghe P4P#1? What's your P4P top 10 list?

[!! Mr. Soprano]

There have been some major fights lately some upsets, some huge wins, some fighters retired, etc... and we haven't done a p4p in a while.. or at least I haven't seen one due to my lack of recent activity on the site...

I honestly don't know what's the best way to sort these guys...

A lot of talent and a lot of close calls..

If I take another look at my list below, I'd probably be saying "WTF was I thinking?".. but at the current moment this is the best that came out of me..

Much disputed list:

Calzaghe
Pacquiao
Hopkins
Vazquez
Chris John
Marquez
Abraham
Margarito
Hatton
Pavlik

[krispy kreme]

Pacman number one, Calzaghe number two.

[S.G.]

Pacman #1 still for sure

can't choose between Marquez and Calzaghe for that 2nd spot though... very close imo

[Wales08]

Calzaghe
Pacquiao
Hopkins
Chris John
Vazquez
Abraham
Marquez
Hatton
Margarito
Pavlik

[!! Mr. Soprano]

IMO Calzaghe justgot the two huge wins this year...
so I moved Pac to #2.. and in a few weeks, we will see if he is really a #1 P4P....

[S.G.]

oh, and this is my top ten currently... the bottom 5 aren't really in a definitive order

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Rafael Marquez
7. Nonito Donaire
8. Ivan Calderon
9. Antonio Margarito
10. Miguel Cotto/Fernando Montiel

i don't feel Marg should be there, but since he beat Cotto i feel obliged to include him

[RichCCFC]

Calzaghe
Pacquiao
Hopkins
Marquez

[larryx]

1 calzaghe
2 calzaghe
3 calzaghe
4 calzaghe
5 calzaghe
6 calzaghe
7 calzaghe
8 calzaghe
9 calzaghe
10 calzaghe

[ИATAS]

Are people seriously placing Calzaghe #1 after beating Jones? Jones wasn't even ranked in the top 10. Maybe Hopkins should be #1 after beating a RANKED pavlik?? lol.

Nothing changes for me:
1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Bernard Hopkins

I don't mind people swapping Marquez with Calzaghe, but peeps are getting a lil too excited with Joe's win over Jones. Come on!

[larryx]

Are people seriously placing Calzaghe #1 after beating Jones? Jones wasn't even ranked in the top 10. Maybe Hopkins should be #1 after beating a RANKED pavlik?? lol.

Nothing changes for me:
1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Bernard Hopkins

I don't mind people swapping Marquez with Calzaghe, but peeps are getting a lil too excited with Joe's win over Jones. Come on!

you didnt get the memo??calzaghe is god now