Calzaghe vs Hagler,duran,leonard or hearns

[celt80]

calzaghe is too big for SRL and Duran, the hitman would have a good chance with his reach and power. hagler is a bit small for a middle as well so I think he would beat 3 out of the 4 ud with the hitman it could be a toss up depending on who gets their game plan to work firts. all beat calzaghe P4P.

[daggum]

calzaghe vs duran- calzaghe makes duran say no mas 5 seconds into the first round
calzaghe vs leonard- calzaghe detaches both of leonard's retinas and beats a blind man half to death
calzaghe vs hagler- calzaghe outboxes hagler so bad he quits boxing for 500 years
calzaghe vs hearns- hearns is ko'd during the ring walk by the thought of calzaghe.

my objective opinion.

[The Hulk]

calzaghe vs duran- calzaghe makes duran say no mas 5 seconds into the first round
calzaghe vs leonard- calzaghe detaches both of leonard's retinas and beats a blind man half to death
calzaghe vs hagler- calzaghe outboxes hagler so bad he quits boxing for 500 years
calzaghe vs hearns- hearns is ko'd during the ring walk by the thought of calzaghe.

my objective opinion.

"Here come the girls!"

Get a life outside disparaging Calzaghe. Most sensible posters already agreed that P4P Calzaghe loses out to these greats.
At the minute you have to be the most obsessive, bitter poster on the forums.
Get a grip man.

This message brought to you by the Hulk!
Grar 2008!

[Mr. Philadel]

if he fought prime duran , leonard , hearns and hagler once each he'd be 0-5.

don't ask me how he'd get 5 losses in 4 fights...... just know that's how it'd be.

0-5?

Joe would beat Ray Leonard(Ray was too small)
Joe would beat Duran(too small, too slow)
Joe could beat Hagler(with flare like Ray Leonard did) by disputed decision
Joe would not beat Hearns(the jab and one-punch KO power is the key.....something none of the other 3 posesses.)styles make fights and Tommy's is the only one that should trouble Joe.

[boxasmash]

hagler wins 15 round ud
calzaghe wins 15 round ud over leonard
calzaghe stops duran around the 8th
calzaghe loses 15 round ud to hearns or stops him in 9th

something like that.