Calzaghe vs Hagler,duran,leonard or hearns

[ericsantos]

how does he do against the fab 4?

[-----------]

Calzaghe KO1

[The Gully Gad]

He slaps the **** outta them

[El Dominicano]

how does he do against the fab 4?

Hearn K.O's him or outboxses him, Calzaghe can get it any way. Duran too small but I'm sure Duran will give him problems. SRL winz eazy. Hagler takez him out

[!! AI-Holmes!!]

A slap fest indeed, well Joe would have to slim down to welter..

[ericsantos]

in my opinion they all school him

[WhoreUs]

if he fought prime duran , leonard , hearns and hagler once each he'd be 0-5.

don't ask me how he'd get 5 losses in 4 fights...... just know that's how it'd be.

[Thread Stealer]

All of them were better p4p than Calzaghe, however, size does matter. There's only so much that skills/talent can do to overcome size, especially when Joe is a very good fighter himself.

Calzaghe would be a light-heavyweight back in earlier days (not just in the last two fights, but most of his career), due to different weigh-in procedures.

I've already been through the Hagler-Calzaghe matchup on a different thread (Hagler should win, but it's still a big question mark if a not-so-big MW like him can made the adjustment to LHW). Duran? Too small. Leonard? I don't think he was very impressive in his SMW fights. Maybe he could win, but the Lalonde/Hearns 2 fights don't exactly inspire the most confidence.

I would need to see the Hearns-Andries fight again to make a better judgement on that matchup.

[T-97]

Calzaghe easily beats them all, too big for Leonard and Duran. Against Hearns and Hagler he would have trouble, but his incredible chin, speed and accumulative power (In his prime) would be too much. I think he has a good chance of TKOing Hearns, but he deffinatly wouldn't stop Hagler.

I'm sure he beats all 4 though.

[larryx]

is this thread serious??????????he'd loose 2 all of them