List of Fighters who called Calzaghe a slapper

[Chunk..]

Workrate being beneficial and workrate being the reason you won are two different things.

Joe wins most of his fights because he's a superior boxer to everyone else?

[Clegg]

Solid list of peope who said that he was slapping that fought him. If Pavlik said he was a slapper I wouldn't add him to the list as he did not fight him.

What makes the list solid then? The fact that it's 5 names long?

And what does it matter if he fought them or not? In most of those cases, the comments were made BEFORE the fight.

Also, cite your sources. Where were these comments made? On TV? In a newspaper? Which one?

[toluco]

Williams has proved he punches do have affect last 2 fights, his punches leave marks on Margarito after the fight unlike Calzaghe over Hopkins.

calzaghe has proven his punches do affect during his entire career just ask jeff lacy
and its pretty easy to showboat when u are fighting guys with no power like quintana or that bum at 160 i bet hes gonna slap around the next powerfull puncher he faces
and i didnt saw any marks on margarito face

[Clegg]

Joe wins most of his fights because he's a superior boxer to everyone else?

Yes, he's a superior to boxer to Kessler and Lacy, which is why he beat them in the way he did. He beat Mitchell because he landed more hard flush shots in the 2nd round, however that was down to a number of factors, not just workrate.

I think the Manfredo fight was a joke, but Calzaghe is a superior boxer.

I don't think Calzaghe beats Hopkins without workrate, but that still only makes you comment 20% true at most IMO.

[Flawless 2]

calzaghe has proven his punches do affect during his entire career just ask jeff lacy
and its pretty easy to showboat when u are fighting guys with no power like quintana or that bum at 160 i bet hes gonna slap around the next powerfull puncher he faces
and i didnt saw any marks on margarito face

Top right eye, there is a mark and small swallowing

[Flawless 2]

Yes, he's a superior to boxer to Kessler and Lacy, which is why he beat them in the way he did. He beat Mitchell because he landed more hard flush shots in the 2nd round, however that was down to a number of factors, not just workrate.

I think the Manfredo fight was a joke, but Calzaghe is a superior boxer.

I don't think Calzaghe beats Hopkins without workrate, but that still only makes you comment 20% true at most IMO.

Kessler Lacy

[Chunk..]

Yes, he's a superior to boxer to Kessler and Lacy, which is why he beat them in the way he did. He beat Mitchell because he landed more hard flush shots in the 2nd round, however that was down to a number of factors, not just workrate.

I think the Manfredo fight was a joke, but Calzaghe is a superior boxer.

I don't think Calzaghe beats Hopkins without workrate, but that still only makes you comment 20% true at most IMO.

Most of that post i would agree with, apart from the bit in bold. Especially the 20% bit.

But it's your opinion so fair play.

[Clegg]

Kessler Lacy

You are the one who brought their names up

[Clegg]

Most of that post i would agree with, apart from the bit in bold. Especially the 20% bit.

But it's your opinion so fair play.

I said 20% because there are 5 boxers and only 1 of them would've beaten him if his workrate was less ie. workrate was only the deciding factor in 20% of the fights mentioned.

[Chunk..]

I said 20% because there are 5 boxers and only 1 of them would've beaten him if his workrate was less ie. workrate was only the deciding factor in 20% of the fights mentioned.

You wanna hug?