Who has the better resume at 130? Floyd Mayweather or Manny Pacquaio?

[boxaholic]

manny was at 130 during a better time

floyd kinda had no option but to move up....he was leaps and bounds above anyone at 130

so i guess pac

floyd was more impressive tho

I agree at 130 pac. As a boxer Floyd.

[NoFear24]

Corrales was actually in his prime when Mayweather beat him, so I'd say Mayweather. Corrales was also on the pound for pound list at the time and has one of the best junior lightweight reigns in recent memory. That win IMO was better than an over the hill Barrerra or Morales.

You say his best win is against Chico. Deigo is great but not as great as JMM or Barrara. His style was to one dimensional. He wasn't versatile enough to beat a skillful boxer. Such as Floyd or even Casa.


An over the hill Barrara won 6 straight fights against tough competition and looked good doing it ( not including his fight with JMM ). The Barrara he fought at 125 was the same Barrara that fought Hamed and beat him. Didn't matter what division Barrara fought Pac in , Pac style is way to aggressive for Barrara. Everytime Barrara would even try and fight back, Pac would just keep attacking non stop. The second fight Pac out boxed and out brawled Barrara.

Barrara is a much greater fighter than Chico is. Much more technically sound in every aspect except for power. He was in the top p4p rankings at the time he fought Barrara at 126. Where still talking about 130 resume, but by Barrara fighting at 130 and winning 6 straight fights in a row, that showed that Pac wins against Barrara was no fluke and Barrara still had plenty in the Tank. Chico is a great fighter but not as great as Barrara . He was very technically flawed and he fought on heart alone most of the time to try and get the KO.

Pac wanted to fight Barrara a couple time at 130 but Barrara declined and fought other people. He knew there was no way for him to beat Pac no matter how mentally or physically prepared he was at 130.

Pacs resume at 130 is still better than Floyds at 130
Pac fights Erik 3 times, fights Barrara, fights JMM, and Larios. His resume is better period.

RESUME AT 130 goes to Pac easy.

Floyd is technically more skillful than Pac, but Pac always want to fight the best whether that be a much bigger Dela Hoya, rematching JMM again or even fighting a bigger hatton. Hell he even says he might want to fight Floyd if he beats Oscar and I give nothing but respect for fighters who are willing to fight the best in the game. GO PACMAN

[Texas Made]

yea i whoever said that Morales and Barrera were past their prime maybe right but Morales and Barrera past their prime still better than most 130's

[wmute]

yea i whoever said that Morales and Barrera were past their prime maybe right but Morales and Barrera past their prime still better than most 130's

based on what? certainly not Morales struggling against chavez and hernandez, whereas Maywether dominated them.

[wmute]

You say his best win is against Chico. Deigo is great but not as great as JMM or Barrara. His style was to one dimensional. He wasn't versatile enough to beat a skillful boxer. Such as Floyd or even Casa.


An over the hill Barrara won 6 straight fights against tough competition and looked good doing it ( not including his fight with JMM ). The Barrara he fought at 125 was the same Barrara that fought Hamed and beat him. Didn't matter what division Barrara fought Pac in , Pac style is way to aggressive for Barrara. Everytime Barrara would even try and fight back, Pac would just keep attacking non stop. The second fight Pac out boxed and out brawled Barrara.

Barrara is a much greater fighter than Chico is. Much more technically sound in every aspect except for power. He was in the top p4p rankings at the time he fought Barrara at 126. Where still talking about 130 resume, but by Barrara fighting at 130 and winning 6 straight fights in a row, that showed that Pac wins against Barrara was no fluke and Barrara still had plenty in the Tank. Chico is a great fighter but not as great as Barrara . He was very technically flawed and he fought on heart alone most of the time to try and get the KO.

Pac wanted to fight Barrara a couple time at 130 but Barrara declined and fought other people. He knew there was no way for him to beat Pac no matter how mentally or physically prepared he was at 130.

Pacs resume at 130 is still better than Floyds at 130
Pac fights Erik 3 times, fights Barrara, fights JMM, and Larios. His resume is better period.

RESUME AT 130 goes to Pac easy.

Floyd is technically more skillful than Pac, but Pac always want to fight the best whether that be a much bigger Dela Hoya, rematching JMM again or even fighting a bigger hatton. Hell he even says he might want to fight Floyd if he beats Oscar and I give nothing but respect for fighters who are willing to fight the best in the game. GO PACMAN

It is not even owrth getting in the details. You are mentioning as pac's great wins at 130 fighters who did not **** at 130. Dismissed

[toluco]

as much as i dislike mayweather he wins
pac doesnt have a good resume at 130
the morales win was at 135 barrera was completely past it the second time, imo he lost both fights to jmm and larios was moving up from 122

[shadeyfizzle]

I dont know who said Floyd is the greatest superfeather of alltime but sorry, there are only 2 acceptable answers to that. Willie pep or flash elorde.

Between floyd and Pac's resume at 130 however, Pac has a loss at 130. Floyd does not.

But it's worth noting that the ring magazine published an article just be4 they got bought by gbp stating that Pacquiao would demolish just as/ if not more easily anyone on Floyd's resume at 130.

[El Dominicano]

I dont know who said Floyd is the greatest superfeather of alltime but sorry, there are only 2 acceptable answers to that. Willie pep or flash elorde.

Between floyd and Pac's resume at 130 however, Pac has a loss at 130. Floyd does not.

But it's worth noting that the ring magazine published an article just be4 they got bought by gbp stating that Pacquiao would demolish just as/ if not more easily anyone on Floyd's resume at 130.

Isn't Pep a 126 pounder?

[shadeyfizzle]

Isn't Pep a 126 pounder?

I meant to say Salvador Sanchez. Sorry. I was thinking Pep cuz keyword was featherweight

[El Dominicano]

I meant to say Salvador Sanchez. Sorry. I was thinking Pep cuz keyword was featherweight

Indeed I agree Salvador Sanchez was Great and in my opinion the greatest Mexican fighter but he died too young to be considered the greatest 130 pounder. Still he beat 2 Great namez in Gomez/Azumah Nelson