All-Time Ranking at 135: Shane Mosley or Jose Luis Castillo

[Shaun Oliver]

Shane ftw. JLC not far behind tho

[Froch You]

I like Mosley head to head but Castillo has the better body of work at Lightweight.

[black.ink]

Mosely would win head to head in their primes, but Castillo did much more at Lightweight and i consider him to be ranked higher.

[Dice]

Mosely would win head to head in their primes, but Castillo did much more at Lightweight and i consider him to be ranked higher.

I dont even think Mosley beats Castillo, Floyd Mayweather is a better boxer in my opinion and Castillo gave him all sorts of hell, and Mosley didnt run at 135, he just stood and ****** which would have gotten him a loss cuz Castillo's chin is like Margaritos. He may have struggled in wins against top notch opponents but Mosley looked great simply cuz his opponents were less then steller.

[JAB5239]

I dont even think Mosley beats Castillo, Floyd Mayweather is a better boxer in my opinion and Castillo gave him all sorts of hell, and Mosley didnt run at 135, he just stood and ****** which would have gotten him a loss cuz Castillo's chin is like Margaritos. He may have struggled in wins against top notch opponents but Mosley looked great simply cuz his opponents were less then steller.

He destroyed both Joh John Molina and Jesse James Leija, both of who will probably end up in Cantasota.

[Sweet Pea 50]

I dont even think Mosley beats Castillo, Floyd Mayweather is a better boxer in my opinion and Castillo gave him all sorts of hell, and Mosley didnt run at 135, he just stood and ****** which would have gotten him a loss cuz Castillo's chin is like Margaritos. He may have struggled in wins against top notch opponents but Mosley looked great simply cuz his opponents were less then steller.

And Mosley is glass chinned? Castillo has been stopped. Mosley? Not once.

[oldgringo]

Castillo has the better Lightweight record but Mosley was a better talent. I'd take Mosley in a head to head match and I'd rank him slightly ahead of Castillo historically.

[SweetScience55]

Castillo has the better Lightweight record but Mosley was a better talent. I'd take Mosley in a head to head match and I'd rank him slightly ahead of Castillo historically.

I agree...