Is #2 Too High a Spot for Calzaghe on the P4P List?

[Ray*]

The most overrated fighter and resume in boxing today is Calzaghe's and that's followed very closely by Hatton. British boxing is so pathetic that their best fighter in the last 50 years had to go learn how to box in Canada.

Calzaghe is wouldnt agree with but Hatton yes i would agree with that, His resume is pretty padded worst than amir khan.

[BlackHat]

1. Clzaghe
2. Hatton
3. Khan



Seriously speaking #2 spot for JOe is Ok for me..

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Calzaghe is wouldnt agree with but Hatton yes i would agree with that, His resume is pretty padded worst than amir khan.

[Rob_Ga_Jahav_74]

My top 5:

1. Pac Man
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Margaritio after win over Cotto
4. Pavlik
5. Marquez

I am getting a bit accustomed to the Calzaghe bashing on this
forum Cal-slappy etc but the fact is you just have to look at his results.

He has wins over the (at the time) next Tyson (Lacey), a win over contender 3 winner Sakio Bika and beat comfortably Mikkel Kessler who I predict will be the future leader in the SM division. (note I leave Manfredo in this list as that was just a US profile raising excercise).

As for B-Hop, listen to the Manny Steward commentary of him during the B-Hop Calzaghe fight on HBO where he acknowledged that Joe put more pressure on Hopkins than any other fighter had put him under. That overlayed with the fact the Compubox had him scoring more punches against B-Hop than ANY other fighter including a 1993 version of RJJ does put him in the upper ecehelons of any P4P boxnig list.

I acknowledge that if this list had Mayeather in it he would be #3 but he DOES deserve a lofty position on results alone.

Finally, please visit my site if you have a second whether you love or hate Joe:

www.calzaghe-fight-news.com

For all the build up, video, news for the Calzaghe Jones fight in December. Built by a boxing fan for boxing fans.

[hugh grant]

I voted No1 p4p but i meant no2 where he should be.
How can you say he hasnt beat anyone. He just beat BH who people had in the top 5.
And BH had just beat AT. Your as good as your last fight. If JC was as bad as some people try and make out, why has noone has been able to expose JC yet? Because if he wasnt great, someone would have exposed him. Even an old BH should have done. Because it is because JC is great.

[P4P Opinion]

Come on Sin, whose alt are you? I refuse to believe that anyone could actually be so spiritually malformed that they could get as much enjoyment out of posting hate threads on a boxing forum as you do. I mean you must have other interests, right? Hobbies?

$in's hobbies: Bowling, pottery, fapping off to videos of Calzaghe being hit while sitting in his own faeces and yoga.

[bsrizpac]

1. Calzaghe
2. Marquez
3. Pacquiao

Cong**** on matching the thread starters ******ity. As usual. Biased ****.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Cong**** on matching the thread starters ******ity. As usual. Biased ****.

Congratulations of once again calling someone ****** or racist for having a different opinion to you.

Is that ALL you do on here?

[bsrizpac]

Congratulations of once again calling someone ****** or racist for having a different opinion to you.

Is that ALL you do on here?

Cong**** on being a ****** racist. Can't help what I see.

You're just as dumb as Sin. It's hilarious that you can't see it.

[The Monk]

I don't see how people can have Joe at number one, Pac is a clear number 1 IMO, but I equally don't understand how people can have him below 2. Its no coincidence that the knowledgeable posters chose the 2nd option.