Who really won Castillo vs Mayweather 1 (Public Poll)

[Flawless]

Damn. the haters have come out of the closest. Ain't a Mexican boxer ever that would beat Mayweather

[Dan...]

It was a very close fight but I had Floyd just ahead. Really could have gone either way though.

[deliveryman]

I don't know how a fighter can lose the first 5 rounds of a fight, and have a point deducted, and still win a decision.

People tend to think Castillo won, because he inflicted more damage in the fight. Sorry fights are scored on a round by round basis, Floyd winning a round landing 10 punches to Castillo`s 3 punches is worth just as much as Castillo winning a round landing 20+ power punches.

Mayweather 114-112
Rounds: 1,2,3,4,5,9,11

Castillo: 6,7,8,10,12

[Dan...]

I don't know how a fighter can lose the first 5 rounds of a fight, and have a point deducted, and still win a decision.

People tend to think Castillo won, because he inflicted more damage in the fight. Sorry fights are scored on a round by round basis, Floyd winning a round landing 10 punches to Castillo`s 3 punches is worth just as much as Castillo winning a round landing 20+ power punches.

Mayweather 114-112
Rounds: 1,2,3,4,5,9,11

Castillo: 6,7,8,10,12

Nice post. This is a pretty accurate assessment both of the fight itself and how it is perceived.

[deliveryman]

And as far as Lederman scoring Mayweather fights goes:

He had Chavez up one or even going into the 9th round before Floyd KO`d him, and was beating him up all night. In fact, prior to the KO, only one judge had given Chavez more than a single round. Even Lampley and Merchant were laughing at him.

Look at the Hatton fight. He gave Hatton what, something like 5 rounds.

[The Gambler1981]

Wow 60-40 just like i said this poll would turn out.

[Dan...]

And as far as Lederman scoring Mayweather fights goes:

He had Chavez up one or even going into the 9th round before Floyd KO`d him, and was beating him up all night. In fact, prior to the KO, only one judge had given Chavez more than a single round. Even Lampley and Merchant were laughing at him.

Look at the Hatton fight. He gave Hatton what, something like 5 rounds.

Lederman has one criteria by which he scores fight - aggression. And he couldn't care less if it is effective or not.

[Clegg]

I don't know how a fighter can lose the first 5 rounds of a fight, and have a point deducted, and still win a decision.

People tend to think Castillo won, because he inflicted more damage in the fight. Sorry fights are scored on a round by round basis, Floyd winning a round landing 10 punches to Castillo`s 3 punches is worth just as much as Castillo winning a round landing 20+ power punches.

Mayweather 114-112
Rounds: 1,2,3,4,5,9,11

Castillo: 6,7,8,10,12

I find it interesting that you mention Castillo's point deduction but not Mayweather's.

[El Dominicano]

I don't know how a fighter can lose the first 5 rounds of a fight, and have a point deducted, and still win a decision.

People tend to think Castillo won, because he inflicted more damage in the fight. Sorry fights are scored on a round by round basis, Floyd winning a round landing 10 punches to Castillo`s 3 punches is worth just as much as Castillo winning a round landing 20+ power punches.

Mayweather 114-112
Rounds: 1,2,3,4,5,9,11

Castillo: 6,7,8,10,12

This is mines



JLC won rounds 4, 6, 7, 9, 12


Both of them had a point taken away.



Mayweather won rounds 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 10, 11

115-113 Mayweather.

[floydfan]

Why does it seem anyone from Britain clearly tries to insult Mayweather is it cause he knocked out there only decent fighter besides Calzaghe.