Who really won Castillo vs Mayweather 1 (Public Poll)

[Patrick Bateman]

It was a very close fight and obviously, Floyd's toughest challenge to date. But I feel Castillo disrupted Floyd's game plan to his favor.

[THE REED]

i had to dig deep to say that cause roy is my guy i wrote a paper on him and everything in college he is a top 20 atg//all great fighters have questionable nights but the great nights should over shadow those

right.. i have a joyous time turning into my calzaghe alt... usually depends on the amount of redbull i drink.

[Omalsi11]

This really says something, when fans have to cling to one of the only close decisions that Floyd Mayweather has had. You may not like him, but you have to admit that if Castillo had been fighting somebody else who had edged out the same kind of win, it wouldn't have been nearly as controversial. Floyd is just in the spotlight and scrutinized more than any other fighter on the planet.

[Tuggers1986]

there have been like 30 polls on this fight. heres one ---> THE ORIGINALhttp://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...llo+mayweather

heres another ---> http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...llo+mayweather

and another ---> http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=139026

and yet another ---> http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...ad.php?t=84379

and yet another ---> http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...ad.php?t=42975

The 3rd one down is mine

[The Gambler1981]

didnt castillo pick up 2 loses from mamyweather???? the polls arnt gonna change the history books so lets move on...... pbf-39-0> castillo shot fighting for money

Look at who i voted for, i feel most people on this board don't know how to properly score a fight. So a 60-40 spread of people who mostly can not score a fight does not mean that much.

[egreezy]

How can you have scored it 116-112 when there was two 1point deductions?

Have you even seen the fight??

I had it 114-112 for Castillo

he knows his boxing i wouldnt question his scoring, lol. last guy that tried didnt get away with it

[larryx]

Look at who i voted for, i feel most people on this board don't know how to properly score a fight. So a 60-40 spread of people who mostly can not score a fight does not mean that much.

well my man let me offer my sincere appoligy

[larryx]

This really says something, when fans have to cling to one of the only close decisions that Floyd Mayweather has had. You may not like him, but you have to admit that if Castillo had been fighting somebody else who had edged out the same kind of win, it wouldn't have been nearly as controversial. Floyd is just in the spotlight and scrutinized more than any other fighter on the planet.

their not fans!!!their the same dumb asses who post a ****ing sparring session wit paul spara=who

[The Hammer]

Castillo clearly won the fight. Anyone who says otherwise is either a Mayweather nuthugger or a liar.

Mexicans are often robbed by the American boxing judges in Las Vegas. Bob Arums fighters, which Floyd was at the time, rarely lose decisions in Vegas - even when they deserve to!

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

floyd by a point