Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG great fighter???

[IMDAZED]

oh so we measure it by flawless's biased and utterly defunct/racist reasoning people..

your right about toney though, the only HOF hes going in is happy eater.

James Toney is most certainly going to the Hall of Fame.

[Flawless]

I suppose, I know what you mean,

Joe will go down as a great super middleweight. But not an All Time Great. I chance my vote to no...

But i still maintain that he is a great Super Middleweight.

I admit that he is a certain Hofer but ATG no way.

Hatton should be a all time great no losses in Jr WW and only lost to P4P best
Tito is not a ATG but he was a great WW fighter
Hopkins is not a ATG but a Hofer maybe

[Flawless]

James Toney is most certainly going to the Hall of Fame.

Yes he will most likely but not a certain ATG.

[j.razor]

He will go down in the HOF for fighting a lot of __________ (you enter the word) and holding a belt for a long time. He waited to long to become something he is not. So IMO no never.

i'll fill it wit unknown BUMS...

[Flawless]

Vote people

[1g5a22]

James Toney is most certainly going to the Hall of Fame.

great buffet on too,he'l love that

[abadger]

Ottke Hatton Kostya Mosley Judah Kessler Eubank Benn Margarito Cotto Forrest are all HOFER


End of sarcasm

They probably all should be, except for Judah and Forrest.

[BattlingNelson]

Ottke Hatton Kostya Mosley Judah Kessler Eubank Benn Margarito Cotto Forrest are all HOFER


End of sarcasm

Michael Carbajal, Edwin Rosario, Bobby Chacon, Pipino Cuevas.

[1g5a22]

Vote people

i vote for capital punishment..

lets hang this plantpot by his ears and drum some sense into his gene pool...

[Flawless]

Calzaghe name should be at the level of Duran Ali Louis Tunney Dempsey JCC Marciano Roy Jones Henry Armstrong Pernell Whitaker Evander Holyfield Marvin Hagler Archie Moore Willie Pep Harry Greb

You think Calzaghe should be up with these boys