Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG great fighter???

[Flawless]

Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG great fighter???

When he retires after RJJ after beating names such as Kessler(unproven) Eubank(Weight drained) and Lacy(The young mike Tyson) will his name be up there with the likes as Ali Duran Leonard Tunney Dempsey Marciano Robinson JCC Roy Jones Holmes Louis and many more. Is he that good??

[TheGreatAli]

I'm saying yes.

Because you want everyone to say no.

Plus...

I think he is anyway.

[Floyd Sinclair]

I think hes a good fighter...hes skilled and he stays busy. Good fighter...but not great

[abadger]

Yes he is. Why are you so opposed to the idea?

[Flawless]

ree****yaluss, The Gold Mac Splinterccfc



Reasons boys

[1g5a22]

im saying my 100m is 10.01 flat with an american on my back.

[Silencers]

He's the greatest super middleweight of all time, not sure about ATG.

[Flawless]

I understand he qualifies for HOFer but a ATG is completely something different. Ali beat a prime Foreman and Liston. Duran beat Leonard, Marciano beat Louis




Calzaghe beat Kessler or Lacy ( young mike tyson)

[Flawless]

im saying my 100m is 10.01 flat with an american on my back.

Vitali still in your top10 list

[T-97]

He is in the position where he has ruled a division that has not existed for as long as most others. So, there are less fighters to rank over him. Roy Jones and James Toney were better IMO, But 168 was really a stepping stone for them where Joe spent a long time there. I think he ranks as the best 168 Pounder in history, up to this point. So, Yes, I guess..