Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG great fighter???

[Flawless]

As wa his hand speed and accuracy, which made his power even better

Agreed, what is Calzaghe styke of Calzaghe defines him, how quick he is not?? Not even that quick Power??? I laugh Ring Intelligence I give him that but no way near Mayweather Ali and others

[Xyei]

His was not great ear but what he has over Calzaghe is that he fought 15 rounds and also had more title defences also his power puncher was awesome what does Calzaghe have that is special??

So are you saying that a fighter must fight 15 rounds to be considered an ATG?

[Flawless]

So are you saying that a fighter must fight 15 rounds to be considered an ATG?

It was harder to fight back then 15 rounds is a huge ask when you are a heavyweight

[BattlingNelson]

As a fan of Joe Louis, I can say, that his division was pretty weak. Had some good fighters on his record though, Schmeling, Sharkey, Wolcott, Conn etc. But most of the guys he beat were not ATGs or anywhere near,

Louis is still one of the greatest Heavyweights of all time though.

Absolutely. I never stated otherwise

I was only trying to concur with Flawless definition.

I know I know. What was I thinking.:alien:



Good points Bat. BatTheMan is an ATG poster...

It was harder to fight back then 15 rounds is a huge ask when you are a heavyweight

So Lewis can never be considered an ATG and neither can anyone else post Tyson.

[Flawless]

Absolutely. I never stated otherwise

I was only trying to concur with Flawless definition.




So Lewis can never be considered an ATG and neither can anyone else post Tyson.

Look at Lewis resume Tyson Holyfield Vitali Golota and now look at Calzaghe

[T-97]

Absolutely. I never stated otherwise

I was only trying to concur with Flawless definition.

I know

Just throwing my views out there on The Brown Bomber

[Xyei]

Look at Lewis resume Tyson Holyfield Vitali Golota and now look at Calzaghe

at using Golota to try to prove your point..

[BattlingNelson]

at using Golota to try to prove your point..

Yeah. I rest my case.

[T-97]

Yeah. I rest my case.

I think Lewis has a good resume, Although he fought in a pretty weak division. Both Tyson and Holyfield were not on their primes by the time Lewis fought them, But he proved his greatness by beating everyone else out there. I can't think of anyone he ducked in his prime (*Waits for someone to mention Vitali*)

[Xyei]

I think Lewis has a good resume, Although he fought in a pretty weak division. Both Tyson and Holyfield were not on their primes by the time Lewis fought them, But he proved his greatness by beating everyone else out there. I can't think of anyone he ducked in his prime (*Waits for someone to mention Vitali*)

Again, just picking Flawlesses flawed logic apart. I feel that Lewis is an ATG HW....

Not trying to be a **** Flawless but your logic is flawed on this subject...

You'd be better off saying that you don't feel that he's an ATG because his resume is week or something instead of making up criteria as you go and having it picked apart by BatTheMan..