Is Margarito the most overrated boxer in history?

[Pico Hollywood]

How is he overrated? He just beat Miguel Cotto who was the undefeated number one guy in the division.

Helena my ass

[Scott9945]

No one thinks Margarito is great besides Mexicans. What do you expect from a population of people without any concept of education?

Really low class post.

[Mr. Ryan]

Helena my ass

[Scott9945]

How is he overrated? He just beat Miguel Cotto who was the undefeated number one guy in the division.

I guess you'd have to be "hater free" to understand.

[Ray*]

I dont think Rito is overrated, I notice that everytime a boxer wins in devastating manner then he gets talked about for about 3 good months, He had that with a lot of boxers on here in the past..E.G When Haye ko enzo people went overboard with how he would be so so and so.

[Haterfree]

Claiming he is the most over rated boxer in history and claiming he has a better career when no one has said that..

You can't even give him props for beating Clottey fair and square and Miguel Cotto.. not to mention being in a close fight with Williams.

No one is saying he is the greatest ever.. he is the best welter right now though. He earned it this July and deserves credit for it. He did what some where afraid to do..

What the **** are you talking about? When did I discredit Margarito's victory over Joshua Clottey or Cotto? Margarito has already loss a UD & his former belt to current WW titleholde Paul Williams. So how can you call him the best WW right now?

[MANGLER]

He only recently rose to serious prominence. Almost every fighter is overrated by the bulk of their fans, since they refuse to see any flaws in their guy. Nobody is callin him greater than any ATG fighters. He's the top WW in the sport right now, and anybody who rates him highly for that is correct. Takin it any further is when it gets questionable.

[Landshark]

No one thinks Margarito is great besides Mexicans. What do you expect from a population of people without any concept of education?

For a poster generalizing a whole nation you are not only uneducated but a racist ****!

[Fox McCloud]

What a ****** ass thread.

No real accomplishments? You mean, apart from knocking the undefeated P4P elite Cotto? Clottey now has an ABC belt, and he holds a win over him. Margarito is a 3 time champ at 147...

He also held onto the WBO belt for a very long time.

Finally the fact that he lost the decision, but didn't really look like he lost the fight against Williams shows that he wasn't dominated by any means.

Do you honestly think that Margarito is more overrated than a Mark Breland? Come on haterfree, try to represent your name with some accuracy.

[Sin City]

What the **** are you talking about? When did I discredit Margarito's victory over Joshua Clottey or Cotto? Margarito has already loss a UD & his former belt to current WW titleholde Paul Williams. So how can you call him the best WW right now?

cus he beat the number one ranked welter
go look at The Ring ratings look who is on top.. hate it or love it, that's what it is.