Margarito is overrated, and the WW is Mediocre.

[IMDAZED]

Name any fighters that have the possibility to be an ATG in that division right now? minus Shane Mosely.

Now look at every divsion 135 and under look at all those great fighters..

lets say Clottey-margarito fight
or Williams vs. Quintana 3

would you rather see those 2 fights or

Juan diaz-Casamayor fight
Katsidis-JMM

or Pacquiao-Campbell
Pacqiuao-Guzman

the divisions under 140 have more marketable fighters and have better match-ups

and the 160 and above aswell

Divisions under 140 have more marketable boxers?

Really? How many more? And define marketable while you're at it.

So now an ATG is needed in order to make a division good? Hey buddy, how many all-time greats are in their prime right now? Or does a division need "past-it" great fighters in order to be good? Kill this thread, please.

[Frozen Butter]

williams is a cry baby? LOL so williams is a crybaby therefore margarito is the best ?

and margarito was cottos 1st big fight? pretty sure mosley was cottos 1st big fight... even though Zab should realistically count.

No I give Margarito credit for beating cotto but thats all, i think he is overrated..

Williams Beat Margarito, but the only way for him to get the chance he deserves is to either rematch quintana again or fight Mosley since arum won't deal with him

[Addition]

so you can think of 1 divisoin thats better and that makes welterweight mediocre??? your a joke!!!

For once I agree with you.

[Haterfree]

How can you call the WW division mediocre? The division has everything. A young up & comer in Berto, 1 of the biggest fights in boxing would be Williams/Margarito 2, & if Floyd comes back the division will hold the best P4P fighter in the world again.

[Pullcounter]

The WW Division is mediocre at best, Alot of fighters in the division was overrated as well, Cotto 1st big fight he lost, Clottey quickly gets injured, Williams is a cry baby, Floyd dissappeared when he was needed most, Quintana got one lucky win and couldn't even execute a good enough game plan in the rematch. Don't even make me mention judah.

Margarito is the best of the overrated fighters, it upsets me this division is so flawed and close to death.. once Margarito loses to clottey the division will be rotting.

the WW division isn't that deep. margarito is overrated. cotto is an 8 round fighter. clottey is injury prone. williams is huge. mosley is old. etc...

the only fight that needs to be made at WW is margarito/williams and margarito is pussing out of that fight.

[Pico Hollywood]

Margarito is a very limited fighter, his chin and his stamina is all he brings to the table.

WW is not the deep at all like i mentioned before in other threads the WW is one big circle jerk

[larryx]

welterweight lost its identiy when floyd left,cotto couldnt carry the torsh/now a jouney man is champ...post floyd..but margo aint bad he's a tough s.o.b

[rizkybizness]

Margarito is a very limited fighter, his chin and his stamina is all he brings to the table.

WW is not the deep at all like i mentioned before in other threads the WW is one big circle jerk

May I watch?

[Pico Hollywood]

May I watch?

I'll ask bob arum to set the date.

[Pico Hollywood]

Divisions under 140 have more marketable boxers?

I stopped reading after that.. Pacquiao, Diaz, Hatton, JMM, Casamayor, Guzman..

Compared to a Margarito, Cotto, Williams, Berto and Clottey..

I think so..