Is Calzaghe HOFer worthy and is he an ATG??

[Clegg]

Eubank wasn't coming out of retirement, he already had a fight scheduled and cancelled it to take the Calzaghe fight.

You've created 7000 Calzaghe threads and you still don't get the simple stuff right?

Anyway, can someone tell me how many ATG's there are, in their opinion?

If 100, then I think a case can be made for Calzaghe being one of the top 100 of all time. If it's more like 30 or so then no.

[IMDAZED]

Eubank wasn't coming out of retirement, he already had a fight scheduled and cancelled it to take the Calzaghe fight.

You've created 7000 Calzaghe threads and you still don't get the simple stuff right?

Anyway, can someone tell me how many ATG's there are, in their opinion?

If 100, then I think a case can be made for Calzaghe being one of the top 100 of all time. If it's more like 30 or so then no.

That's a great question. I propose we make a list of ATG's and breakdown who qualifies, who doesn't.

[Flawless.]

Good idea. Break it down in weight classes first

[S.G.]

don't know.

but he definitely is a British all time great which is something in itself and means he'll always be remembered among boxing enthusiasts over here

[Jim Jeffries]

Looks like the threadstarter is getting so far. I'd say HOF worthy yes, ATG no, so I'm not going to vote.

[Flawless.]

What is it with OWNED on his forum. I have said it a few times but it mainly for Warcraft players. You do say like really gaming geek.

[Dynamite Kid]

Looks like the threadstarter is getting so far. I'd say HOF worthy yes, ATG no, so I'm not going to vote.

Tunney goes away out comes Jim Jeffries

[ALT-Assassin]

Tunney goes away out comes Jim Jeffries

I think Jim Jeffries is Mike Tysons77 ALT

[-----------]

What is it with OWNED on his forum. I have said it a few times but it mainly for Warcraft players. You do say like really gaming geek.

That doesn't make any ****ing sense

[Thread Stealer]

Hall of Famer, yes.

ATG? That's rather subjective on what exactly an ATG is. Usually I think of ATGs as guys being in say, top 30, maybe top 40 all-time.

So no.