Is Calzaghe HOFer worthy and is he an ATG??

[abadger]

I ****ed up hard on this poll. I should have had a HOFer not ATG choice
Where would you rank him in the P4P ATG

No idea, but nowhere near the top.

[Flawless.]

No idea, but nowhere near the top.

Top 10 top 20 top 30 top 40 top 50 which one

[abadger]

Top 10 top 20 top 30 top 40 top 50 which one

To be truthful Guled, I don't know. There are a lot of good fighters in history, and I know approx 1% of them, if that. I have no doubt that Calzaghe is an all time great boxer around his weight though, take whatever the accepted list of MW - LHWs is and stick him at the bottom if you like.

[T-97]

Top 10 top 20 top 30 top 40 top 50 which one

Out of those, I would chose Top 50, I don't think Calzaghe would match well against the likes of Prime Hopkins, Toney, Jones Jr, (Archie) Moore etc.

[garryd]

There are alot of fighters past and present i would prefer to watch over Calzaghe But You just gotta give it to Calzaghe ,love him or hate him hes achieved more than enough to be ATG !
In ten years he made 21 Title defenses capturing all 4 belts whilst beating 8world champions !
He also moved up and beat Hopkins for the Light heavyweight ring belt !
I think its silly to say hes not an all time great and if you are your opinion is dubious IMO !

[UKDan]

i think he is defo a HOFer and prob sc****s in as an ATG too, i blame his promoter for his resume (which isnt as bad as we all make out) but he beat who was put infront of him and thats all you can do as a boxer!

[daggum]

has anyone seen this clown fight? you put this dude in the hall of fame you might as well burn it down to the ground and piss on it cause boxing is over.

[garryd]

has anyone seen this clown fight? you put this dude in the hall of fame you might as well burn it down to the ground and piss on it cause boxing is over.

There are alot of fighters past and present i would prefer to watch over Calzaghe But You just gotta give it to Calzaghe ,love him or hate him hes achieved more than enough to be ATG !
In ten years he made 21 Title defenses capturing all 4 belts whilst beating 8world champions !
He also moved up and beat Hopkins for the Light heavyweight ring belt !
I think its silly to say hes not an all time great and if you are your opinion is dubious IMO

[daggum]

There are alot of fighters past and present i would prefer to watch over Calzaghe But You just gotta give it to Calzaghe ,love him or hate him hes achieved more than enough to be ATG !
In ten years he made 21 Title defenses capturing all 4 belts whilst beating 8world champions !
He also moved up and beat Hopkins for the Light heavyweight ring belt !
I think its silly to say hes not an all time great and if you are your opinion is dubious IMO

im guessing you haven't seen him fight. you can name all his accomplishments but when you watch him do actual "boxing" you will **** your pants in laughter.

[T-97]

im guessing you haven't seen him fight. you can name all his accomplishments but when you watch him do actual "boxing" you will **** your pants in laughter.

I like Joe, But this dude ^ Is funny.