P4P best: Muhammad Ali or Roy Jones Jr?

[PrettyBoyFloyd7]

Prime Jones beats Calzaghe, todays Jones doesn't.

so thats what Joe does huh? Goes around trying to fight all the old men with big names?? He needs to man up and fight Pavlik.

[Darkstar]

Both were great fighters. Ali came through adversity and beat some of the best fighters that the HW division has ever seen, and was the first to be a three time Heavyweight Champ. Roy Jones, on the other hand spanned his career from 154 all the way to Heavyweight, and dominating almost all of his opponents on the way to the top. If you really think about it...If Roy wouldve retired after Ruiz, he wouldve retired at 48 wins,1 loss (which was a DQ to Montell Griffin) as a champ in 4 different weight divisions. If Roy would've retired after the Ruiz bout, and let it soak in, about 10 years after that win, fans would be comparing him to Sugar ray robinson in the all time p4p fighters. But since he got KO'd twice since then, THEY MUSTA FORGOT, what exactly Roy did for boxing.

Yeah all those years and the only thing to show is a close 7 round to 5decision over a green Hopkins and a weight drained James Toney. YALL MUSTA FORGOT

[Jimmy Dean]

I'm not even sure this should be a question. RJJ was a great fighter but in no way did he beat the competition that Ali did. Ali fought the very best of his time and beat them all, whereas RJJ did nothing of the sort.

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

I'm not even sure this should be a question. RJJ was a great fighter but in no way did he beat the competition that Ali did. Ali fought the very best of his time and beat them all, whereas RJJ did nothing of the sort.

Ali beat the toughest opponent of all the US Government....END OF THREAD.......LEFTY

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Prime Jones beats Calzaghe, todays Jones doesn't.

A prime Jones makes quick work of Calzaghe,,,,,Possible KO........Ali would beat a prime Jones by KO....Lefty..

[hishaam15]

lol u cant compare the two fighters. ali was a natural HW whereas RJJ was a natural SMW/LHW...

RJJ was the greatest athlete, dont know about boxer



the question should be comparing RJJ and SRL as p4p greatest

[duffgun]

I was kinda taking the piss anyway i dont like P4P lists and things like that.

[Truth]

Just to clear up in not a super nuthugging Calzaghe fan, the Joe in my boxing scene name is because Joe is my real name and not as

let me see your drivers license...just kidding.

[BetterCallSaul]

Ali did not lose to Tarver, Johnson, Traver. So, I guess I would pick Ali.

[El Dominicano]

Ali did not lose to Tarver, Johnson, Traver. So, I guess I would pick Ali.

****** thing to say. Many posters here have no idea on what its like to be weight drain