Whos the greatest fighter of all time?

[cple]

What I find interesting is how you rank Chavez over Whitaker when Whitaker clearly beat 'em..

Though i do rank Whitaker over Chavez, beating one opponent doesn't automatically make you greater.

[cple]

1.Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Harry Greb
4.JCC
5.Ali
6. Joe Louis
7. Roberto Duran
8.Marvin Hagler
9. Larry Holmes
10. Roy Jones Jr.
11. Mike Tyson
12.Pernell Whitaker
13.Evander Holyfield
14. Erik Morales
15.James Toney

Roy Jones, Holyfield, and especially Tyson, Morales, and Toney do not belong anywhere near the top 15. Jones and Holyfield are probably top 25-30. Other than that, the list is fine, except i wouldn't rank Chavez that high.

[jack_the_rippuh]

I would also put Sugar Ray Leonard somewhere in there..

[psychopath]

What I find interesting is how you rank Chavez over Whitaker when Whitaker clearly beat 'em..

That's his personal opinion . . . but I also find it strange putting JCC above Ali's name.

[BRONXBULL]

Marciano hands downs but if lamotta would have stayed clean and kept his mind strictly on boxing with a heart like his and his toughness i think he could be right up there and you cant forget ray robinson and archie moore and ali is overrated

[Loco671]

Sugar Ray Robinson

[TheGreat1]

i really can't see anyone beating RJJ in his prime. How could you beat him, without being able to hit him?

[riz]

ali hands down

[SonnyJ]

kostya tszyu is my definition of a great fighter. I did not get the opportunity to watch all of them so i will leave it at that.

[DiegoFuego]

Floyd Mayweather has a great shot at being the greatest fighter ever. I'm all for it.