New ESPN's P4P List

[Feint]

I always find these lists to be silly. Pound-for-pound is flawed simply because they are too subjective. But no matter what criteria you use no offense to Hopkins or his fans, but I serious doubt he belongs on any of them.

[joseph5620]

How is a guy on a 2-3 run in the top 20, let alone at #4?

How is a guy who has never won a big fight on there? I'm talking about Juan Manuel Marquez

[joseph5620]

so you think the W or L is more important than the performance and reality of the situation

If that was the case then Paul Wiliams has to be on that list. And what about Joan Guzman? That list was terrible.

[KILLA RIGHT]

He beat Barrera and beat manny twice. Plus Dan had jmm beating manny like most people

[joseph5620]

He beat Barrera and beat manny twice. Plus Dan had jmm beating manny like most people

Dan can think what he wants but Marquez did not beat Manny.You can't rewrite history. And Barrera was way past his prime.You can't seriously use that as an example.