Who is more overrated? Hopkins or Calzaghe?

[abadger]

prime benn , prime eubank and prime collins would've all whooped joe imo.

yet joe is the greater fighter? sad......

They might have beat the version of Joe we saw in his twenties, but I don't think any of them could have beaten the Joe that beat Kessler. I believe they may even have said words to this effect, but I'm not certain about that.

[Boogie Nights]

here's what Tunney had to say about Bernard Hopkins

Kessler is by far the better real boxer.

Hopkins relies heavily on head butts, low blows, hitting and holding, and other illegal means. Without his dirty tricks, he's have been a journeyman.

[RichCCFC]

prime benn , prime eubank and prime collins would've all whooped joe imo.

yet joe is the greater fighter? sad......

You better be joking



25 year old Calzaghe whooped 31 year old Eubank and 118-110 and knocked him down twice and Eubank was the best of those 3.

[Left Hook Tua]

here's what Tunney had to say about Bernard Hopkins

you and tunney................ lol

did you read my post in the comments and suggestions forum?

[RichCCFC]

They might have beat the version of Joe we saw in his twenties, but I don't think any of them could have beaten the Joe that beat Kessler. I believe they may even have said words to this effect, but I'm not certain about that.

Yup.

Benn said Calzaghe would have beaten all three but been in a lot more wars.

[Left Hook Tua]

You better be joking



25 year old Calzaghe whooped 31 year old Eubank and 118-110 and knocked him down twice and Eubank was the best of those 3.

nope not joking.

prime eubank , benn and collins beats prime joe. just my opinion.

eubank was not the best of the 3 either. i liked nigel.

[Left Hook Tua]

Yup.

Benn said Calzaghe would have beaten all three but been in a lot more wars.

benn wasn't serious.

deep down he's thinking , "i would've whooped this fool."

[Tuggers1986]

Personally I think that Hagler is the most overrated MW of all time, and has nothing on either of these boys.

Honest.

WHAT THE ****!!!!!

I'm not even going to argue or try to make you see the light. I can't be arsed wasting my time.

[Drunk Punch]

If Calzaghe keeps his zero and beats RJJ and Pavlik then I would put him clearly ahead of Hopkins. I agree with Tua though, neither are ATGs in my book, hall of famers yes but ATG nope.

[Boogie Nights]

you and tunney................ lol

did you read my post in the comments and suggestions forum?

i posted a response