Mistakes people make in "scoring" fights

[Live Dog]

tua ate 5 bull horns 30 minutes before the lewis fight.





true story.

I wouldn't call that a fight....

[rizkybizness]

I wouldn't call that a fight....

lol. Live Dog is trying Tua......ooooooooooooo... FIGHT FIGHT FIGHT

[-Hyperion-]

i would say a lot of people assume some punches "hurt" the other guy just cus its powerful....i mean, to me the fighter who gets punched must give a clear cut sign of getting hurt(buckled knees, rubbery legs, going down, etc)...otherwise, youre just guessing...i dont see how a punch that looks powerful buts is well received by the other guy is more effective than 4-3 solid punches that land clean and keep the puncher at bay easily...because in the end of the day punches are scored by cleanliness and effectiveness....

[rizkybizness]

i would say a lot of people assume some punches "hurt" the other guy just cus its powerful....i mean, to me the fighter who gets punched must give a clear cut sign of getting hurt(buckled knees, rubbery legs, going down, etc)...otherwise, youre just guessing...i dont see how a punch that looks powerful buts is well received by the other guy is more effective than 4-3 solid punches that land clean and keep the puncher at bay easily...because in the end of the day punches are scored by cleanliness and effectiveness....

Not if Calzaghe is fighting.

[kayjay]

Everybody does #2 sometimes.

[Scott9945]

The 10/8 round is a tough one. Some knowledgeable people insist you should never give it without a KD. I'm undecided.

I don't believe that for a minute. Same with automatically giving a 10-8 round if there is a knockdown like Lederman does.

[kayjay]

I don't believe that for a minute. Same with automatically giving a 10-8 round if there is a knockdown like Lederman does.

I'm not with you. You don't give 9-9 rounds after a KD, do you? The KD is an automatic point; that's not debatable. What is debatable is whether the KD also wins the round. I side with Lederman, I'm sorry to admit.

[Scott9945]

Teddy just gave Mendoza a 10-8 round against lacy without a knockdown

It hardly deserved it.

I agree with that. But I would have given Mendoza a two point round after Lacy tackled him to avoid being stopped. The ref should have taken a point away from Lacy anyway if he wasn't in Golden Boy's pocket.

[El Dominicano]

SRL fought Durans fight and did a really good job. Duran beat SRL, that I know. Really, what if SRL would have boxed?? The way he was suppose?? Duran disrespected SRL's wife and ****. That was Duran's plan. So yeah, I'm talking about number 1.

[El Dominicano]

I'm not with you. You don't give 9-9 rounds after a KD, do you? The KD is an automatic point; that's not debatable. What is debatable is whether the KD also wins the round. I side with Lederman, I'm sorry to admit.

KD doesn't win the round. That shouldn't be debatable.