There is no case for Whitaker beating Oscar

[RAESAAD]

Aren't you the one that still thinks Hopkins and Wright beat Taylor?

Well Hops/Taylor I could have been a draw.....But yes cleary Winky won.

[DiegoFuego]

are you kidding? The Tito fight was the easiest to score of all of the fights I've done. Oscar completely dominated that fight. I even gave Trinidad a close round Oscar could have won. It was that lopsided. Even in the last 4 rounds where Oscar is apparently running he wins 2 of the rounds.

[Fox McCloud]

what do you mean?

Bad case of ADD causes my mind to wander sometimes, and halfway through the round, I'll realize that I haven't been keeping a tally of what has happened in the round in my head up to that point.

I also find it to take away from my enjoyment of watching a fight, so I don't score things round by round anymore. I can generally kind of tell who is winning without going round by round, when I see Lederman's scorecard, and what I would have changed, but...

I'm also not very good at scoring close fights. I find it extremely difficult to pick between two guys in a round that was very close.

I will never understand how Whitaker has more fans than Mayweather. Mayweather is a Whitaker that actually hits back

Oh wait I know why. Because Whitaker's been retired for some years.

Mayweather rolls punches off of his shoulder, which is badass, but Whitaker ducking and dodging punches like he did in that flurry at the end of one of the rounds against Oscar was just insanely good. That is the kind of **** that can catch a newcomers eye, and make Whitaker a fan.

[K-Nan]

Hey Fuego. Whittaker ALWAYS clowned. That had nothing to go with him 'not being able to fight the same way'.

[DiegoFuego]

Well Hops/Taylor I could have been a draw.....But yes cleary Winky won.

says the #1 Winky and B-Hop fan on boxingscene

[xcaret]

whitaker is overrated by boxing fans, all he did was **** around and not fight, sure he made people miss but how the **** does that make u win a fight?

[Dirt E Gomez]

are you kidding? The Tito fight was the easiest to score of all of the fights I've done. Oscar completely dominated that fight. I even gave Trinidad a close round Oscar could have won. It was that lopsided. Even in the last 4 rounds where Oscar is apparently running he wins 2 of the rounds.

I'll never understand how anybody scored a fight like that for Tito. They were worried it was gonna' be a shutout so they gave him rounds earlier they shouldn't have, and that ended up costing Oscar the fight. That result will always piss me off.

[RAESAAD]

says the #1 Winky and B-Hop fan on boxingscene

Are you ******ed? I've never been a big fan of Hopkins. I only really like Winky because he's from my Town.....I call em like I see em dip****. Many others would agree with both of our statements.....why does your silly ass make it sound so 'far' fetched? Everyone knows when someone doesn't agree with you...They are complete morons......which proves that you're reall y the moron.

[Fox McCloud]

Aren't you the one that still thinks Hopkins and Wright beat Taylor?

It's pretty clear that you generally score the round for the harder puncher if he is able to land more than a few shots, even if he is outlanded by a softer puncher.

That's my impression after hearing that you had Oscar over Whitaker and Taylor over Wright.

I guess I'm more of a volume guy. I thought Wright walked away with the Taylor fight. I didn't see a lot of those "hard right hands that split the guard" actually splitting the guard or landing.

[Texasboy34]

Aren't you the one that still thinks Hopkins and Wright beat Taylor?

Hopkins/Taylor 1 - Draw
Hopkins/Taylor 2 - 115 - 113 Taylor
Wright/Taylor - 115 - 113 Winky... I can see 116 - 112 Winky as well.