There is no case for Whitaker beating Oscar

[Dynamite Kid]

Did u see the punchstats for Floyd/Castillo I ?

or Calzaghe v Hopkins LOL

[steptwome]

Countless individuals will have conflicting views of that fight....In the end Whitaker was in the.. no making way, for a promising "YOUNG STAR"

[Sithis]

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ talks.

Oscar doesnt deserve to be talked about as sometihng special. has been given too many gifts.

[Dynamite Kid]

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ talks.

Oscar doesnt deserve to be talked about as sometihng special. has been given too many gifts.

Quartey ,Sturm

what other gifts has he gotten he beat Mosley second time ,he arguably beat Trinidad

[steptwome]

Quartey ,Sturm

what other gifts has he gotten he beat Mosley second time ,he arguably beat Trinidad

Whitaker, Quartey and undeniably Felix Sturm

[Sithis]

Quartey ,Sturm

what other gifts has he gotten he beat Mosley second time ,he arguably beat Trinidad

just whitaker, sturm, and quartay. which is moe than enough. those are huge fights which made huge differenec eon his legacy. victoris he truly doesnt deserve. Oscar was never a middleweight champion if you ask me. bull****.

[Dynamite Kid]

just whitaker, sturm, and quartay. which is moe than enough. those are huge fights which made huge differenec eon his legacy. victoris he truly doesnt deserve. Oscar was never a middleweight champion if you ask me. bull****.

as far as im concerned he should not have beaten Whitaker but Whitaker did not deserve to win either

[Sithis]

as far as im concerned he should of not have beaten Whitaker but Whitaker did not deserve to win either

but whitaker was the champ.

[Dynamite Kid]

but whitaker was the champ.

so what i understand u have to take the title but u also have to defend your title Whitaker fought like a coward IMO

[Boofdatruth]

Just scored it again as I have been all of De La Hoya's close/controversial battles this month. I had it 115-111 for Oscar.

Oscar stole a close round or two based on more effective punching. Whitaker spent this whole fight going backwards and clowning, which is something you do when you don't like getting hit. He obviously was.

In the past, I used to accept scorecards that had it a draw, but watching it again the judges were actually pretty spot on. One had the same score as me while the other two each gave Oscar an extra round. They were slightly too wide but nothing unbelievable. I would love for a Whitaker fan to explain to me how he won this fight. Really, if a Whitaker fan can show me 6 rounds he won, I would love to hear why.

So thus far I have scored the fights

Whitaker-De La Hoya: 115-111 De La Hoya
De La Hoya-Quartey: 114-111 Quartey
De La Hoya-Trinidad: 117-111 De La Hoya
De La Hoya-Mosley I: 115-113 Mosley

I rooted for Dlh, but Dlh didn't beat Pea. He never really connected on Pea. His aggression of looking like he landed won him the fight. They didn't even want to rematch PEa either. Arum. The punch stats for fights are usually off, but in this fight, a fight where both guys missed a lot, I thought Pea should've kept his titles. Dlh threw a bunch of flurries, and missed. He also knocked dlh down too though flash knockdown