Antonio tarver is the worlds best light heavyweight

[p4pkingfloyd]

I get where you are coming from. But Tarver doesn't have great stamina (IMO) and i think Calzaghes workrate would wear him down. But that's my opinion, we will only see who is right if they ever fight, which i doub they will as Calzaghe is fighting Jones then probably retiring.

he is clever and conserves energy, i would have loved to see him fight calzaghe but it wont happen, i think tarver would beat calzaghe

[Fox McCloud]

tarver beat roy in all three fights imo, i think tarver would beat roy at any stage

Learn to score a fight.

Tarver won his 5 rounds as convincingly as you can possibly win rounds, but... He took 7 rounds off, which is the sure formula for a decision loss.

[Dan...]

tarver beat roy in all three fights imo, i think tarver would beat roy at any stage

Well, then, you have some fairly serious issues.

[T-97]

tarver beat roy in all three fights imo, i think tarver would beat roy at any stage

The first fight was close, but to me, Tarver did all his work in a few rounds rather than over the distance so Roy just nicked it. I had it 7 rounds to 5 for Jones. The second fight there is no debating! and in the third fight Roy didn't do anything apart from in Round 5 (Where he looked fantastic and had tarver in trouble, if he carried on like that i think he would have won)

As for Tarver winning at any stage i must disagree, i think prime for prime Roy would wipe the floor with him.

[p4pkingfloyd]

Learn to score a fight.

Tarver won his 5 rounds as convincingly as you can possibly win rounds, but... He took 7 rounds off, which is the sure formula for a decision loss.

hey it was a very close fight, i think it could have gone either way,

tarver beat the **** out of roy in that

[T-97]

hey it was a very close fight, i think it could have gone either way,

tarver beat the **** out of roy in that

He did beat Roy up a bit, but he only did that work in some rounds IMO. As i said in a previous post i think that Tarver didn't do enough work over the 12 rounds to win, he did it all over 5 rounds IMO.

[abadger]

Of the current LHW champs, Tarver has the best record at that weight, but he would probably lose to Hopkins, Calzaghe and maybe Dawson so its doubtful he is actually the best.

[El Jesus]

he has the best record out of any light heavyweight,he only lost hopkins because he was weight drained,this is the guy that finished roy jones,he is back and he gonna become the undisputed champion,

how can calzaghe be the best lhw after one fight in the division that **** aint right

tarver is the man at 175

calzaghe would never wanna fight him. calzaghe only after what tarver finished

Tarver just post under your real name and stop lying.

[T-97]

Tarver just post under your real name and stop lying.

LMAooooo

[Drunk Punch]

Calzaghe has no intention of proving himself at LHW, so the debate about Tarver is a bit pointless.

Calzaghe just wants a giant pay day before his retirement and RJJ represents the best option for making money.