Did Pacquiao surpass JCC Sr. in greatness?

[Boofdatruth]

Its a running joke implying Marquez is a panzy when held up to the mexican warrior mentality with his history of turning down fights and backing up and counterpunching as opposed to going to war

Man, he must have his facts twisted then lol.

[Boofdatruth]

Just to see where you're coming from. The way I see it is that it was just as savage 1 sided beating. The difference being Mayweather essentially gave chico an education while pacman essentially mugged ledwaba

I hear you. Ledwaba was not ranked pfp though.

[shadeyfizzle]

Man, he must have his facts twisted then lol.

Nah...he knows his ****. Just 1 of those you had to be there to get it type of things i guess

[shadeyfizzle]

I hear you. Ledwaba was not ranked pfp though.

As far as I recall neither was Corales at the time floyd beat him

[Silencers]

As far as I recall neither was Corales at the time floyd beat him

Corrales was ranked number 5 pound for pound by the Ring magazine when Mayweather beat him.

[shadeyfizzle]

Corrales was ranked number 5 pound for pound by the Ring magazine when Mayweather beat him.

Well my apologies then.

But remind me why boof feels that deserves more credit than Pacquiao beating a Barrera who was ranked 3rd p4p at the time??

[Silencers]

Well my apologies then.

But remind me why boof feels that deserves more credit than Pacquiao beating a Barrera who was ranked 3rd p4p at the time??

They both deserve credit, great performances from both, I don't think one deserves more credit over the other.

[Boofdatruth]

Well my apologies then.

But remind me why boof feels that deserves more credit than Pacquiao beating a Barrera who was ranked 3rd p4p at the time??

Barrera didn't fight back, chico tried. Floyd did it with precision punching, and fought a great all around fight. Barrera just coverd up, and Pac just Mr. Left-righted him. Floyd showed style against a man who was knocking everyone out. Barrera was starting to look used up, and his performance showed it.

[miron_lang]

Pacman is a great fighter, but please don't compare him to JC Chavez. Chavez fought and beat many more greater fighters.

What?? Many more? list it down pls.

[BennyST]

Please read our entire discussion before sidebusting.

Neither myself nor blackirish compared Pacquiao to JCC sr. nor does the context of overrated" stem from the comparison stated by the threadstarter

Sidebusting? Yeah, ok.

i was talking about his whole which is titled "Did Pac surpass JCC in greatness?". Therefore, I would say maybe you should read the whole thread as that is exactly what this thread is about. This context of overrated stems from people saying who Pac has fought and beat in comparison to JCC. That is where overrated comes into play here.

I wasn't talking about Blackirish. He seems to be on the ball. What I'm saying is that anyone here who thinks there should be any comparison made whatsoever between the two is either highly deluded, has no memory (or just has no idea who anyone is outside Pac) or just plain a over zealous Pacfan.

This thread has turned from comparing Pac to Chavez, which is utterly absurd, to comparing his wins against Mayweathers. This came about because of a dominant performance over Diaz?