..Who's Better: MAYWEATHER Or WHITAKER?...

[THe TRiNiTY]

Also, along with me, Sin City, slicksouthpaw16 and blackirish137 all voted for Whitaker. Are these names that have hatred for Mayweather? I certainly don't. He's an INCREDIBLY GREAT fighter, I'd never deny that.

Thread Stealer, warp1432, SkillsPayBills, Black Jesus and El Dominicano all went with too hard to call. It's clearly NOT that clear. Those are guys that have never really BAD MOUTHED Mayweather.

(I'm pretty sure the names I mentioned have no hatred for Mayweather)

If someone just happens to like Whitaker better, that's the way it is. Doesn't mean they are discrediting him.

[Burner]

Why should it be clearer?

He fought bigger fighters, in their primes and beat them, or should have beat them

Both were p4p number one at one point, bth had incredible skills and Whitaker though not a champion in as many different divisions, chased big fights to other divisions, sometimes passed his prime to do it and had success.

He got robbed in his Chavez and De La Hoya fights, by a lot of peoples accounts, so I don't take those two into anything more than good performances by Whitaker.

Both were fast, both were defensive (though Whitaker was funner to watch while being defensive), both had decent power for guys who aren't looked at as power punchers, both had solid enough beards and both fought the best they could, for the most part.

To say it's clear FOR EITHER, is biased.

iM NOT TALKING ACCOMPLISHMENTS....

Im saying put Floydnext to sweet pea and with a naked eye...Floyd is a better fighter thensweet pea.

[THe TRiNiTY]

iM NOT TALKING ACCOMPLISHMENTS....

Im saying put Floydnext to sweet pea and with a naked eye...Floyd is a better fighter thensweet pea.

Nah, I don't see that. And that isn't what this thread was about anyway.

It was about who was the better fighter, not who wins.

Regardless, I think at 135, it's a VERY close fight. I don't care who he beat or how he beat them at 135, Mayweather didn't fight Whitaker at 135 and it's a close fight.

[VIVA MEXICO!!]

whitaker proved himself by fighting the best. mayweather never did.

[Burner]

whitaker proved himself by fighting the best. mayweather never did.

Thanks for ruining a good thread with good boxing discussion.