were max baer and joe walcott all time greats

[Boogie Nights]

Not great fighter of that era, great fighter in any era.

Not to take anything away from Johnson but he got Jones at the right time.

Jones being great is debatable.

if roy was fightin P4P as you say, he would be great in any era. just i guess as ezzard charles would be

[Silencers]

why not agree that they both were really good journeyman who had their moments? that dont make them into all time greats

Joe Walcott was a journeyman in the early part of his career, he became a great fighter.

[Boogie Nights]

Joe Walcott was a journeyman in the early part of his career, he became a great fighter.

if he became a great fighter, he would have finsihed the job off convincingly against louis and marciano, he lost twice officially to the best legitimate heavyweights of his era. he's not an all time great

[Silencers]

if roy was fightin P4P as you say, he would be great in any era. just i guess as ezzard charles would be

As I said, Jones being great is debatable.

[Silencers]

if he became a great fighter, he would have finsihed the job off convincingly against louis and marciano, he lost twice officially to the best legitimate heavyweights of his era. he's not an all time great

We'll just agree to disagree.

[Boogie Nights]

As I said, Jones being great is debatable.

for you it is, doesnt count for the majority of people. you wouldnt have said that in the 90s.

[Silencers]

for you it is, doesnt count for the majority of people. you wouldnt have said that in the 90s.

I was saying that in the 90's.

[Boogie Nights]

We'll just agree to disagree.

i cant agree with something as absurd as this. i mean calling walcott great is extreme, calling him an all time great, i mean......it's just inapropriate to question another person's knowledge which you did after making a statement like that

[Boogie Nights]

I was saying that in the 90's.

alot of people were saying different

[Silencers]

i cant agree with something as absurd as this. i mean calling walcott great is extreme, calling him an all time great, i mean......it's just inapropriate to question another person's knowledge which you did after making a statement like that

We can go on about this all day, all night and it won't get us anywhere.

alot of people were saying different

I was impressed with his skills and I always said, he can be great. Whether he is great, is debatable.