who are A,B,C Class fighters in your opinion

[markosg]

All I'm saying is that it was an SD that should not have been an SD.

But this is my point.............. an prime oscar would have beaten him if a past one could run him reasonably close.

[Live Dog]

But this is my point.............. an prime oscar would have beaten him if a past one could run him reasonably close.

It was not reasonably close. I had it 8-4 in favor of Mayweather, and I cannot remember a single meaningful punch that ODLH landed.

[markosg]

It's a little naive to say that two fighters that have failed on the big stage on multiple occasions would beat a fighter that never has.

It's not naive to watch a fight and recognise excellent technical ability and form an opinion based on what you see. It is naive to say that just cause Mayweather has won all his fights he would not lose to any fighter which is the logic that your argument is based!

[Live Dog]

It's not naive to watch a fight and recognise excellent technical ability and form an opinion based on what you see. It is naive to say that just cause Mayweather has won all his fights he would not lose to any fighter which is the logic that your argument is based!

Mayweather is by far the most technical of the 3

It is only part of the logic with which my arguement would be based

[S.G.]

Like him or not, Mayweather is the standard that every other fighter is measured by. And yes, he is better than prime Oscar was.

damn b i got a phatter arse than that japanese broad in your avi

that's just nasty

[markosg]

Mayweather is by far the most technical of the 3

It is only part of the logic with which my arguement would be based

How can you say one fighter is more technical than the other??????? it's not somethinf you can measure because they each have verying techniques.

[Dynamite Kid]

How can you say one fighter is more technical than the other??????? it's not somethinf you can measure because they each have verying techniques.

i think its safe to say Eric Morales throws his right hands straighter than Ricardo Mayorga & Floyd uses shorter hooks than Calzaghe

[Live Dog]

How can you say one fighter is more technical than the other??????? it's not somethinf you can measure because they each have verying techniques.

How can you not? You just said.....

It's not naive to watch a fight and recognise excellent technical ability and form an opinion based on what you see.

[markosg]

i think its safe to say Eric Morales throws his right hands straighter than Ricardo Mayorga & Floyd uses shorter hooks than Calzaghe

I don't mean in general.............

But does that apply/matter when talking about a prime Oscar / Floyd / Mosely?

There is hardly that level of disparity........and that reationale can't be used to simply explain why Floyd would hae beaten them both

[baya]

who are A,B,C Class fighters in your opinion

A Class : Elite

B Class : very good but not Great

C Class average /decent


Elite : Jones JR ,Mosley ,Dela Hoya ,Calzaghe ,Hopkins,Pacman ,Barrera ,Morales ,Lewis ,Holy,Tyson,
Whitaker,Chavez ,Floyd ,Toney ,McCallum,Foreman,Winky,Cotto,Tito

B Class : Eubank ,Corrales ,Castillo ,Benn ,Gatti ,Hatton ,Pavlik,Judah ,J Taylor ,

C Class :C. Baldomir ,G Rees ,V Nardiello ,Steve Robinson ,


this may stur up a hornets nest but im gonna run with it anyway if u dont agree fair enoough but lets keep it civil ,add your own lists these are just the fighters that spring to mind thier are plenty more ive have forgotten

this is actually a very good list, kudos to you!