Which fighter has the better Resume/Legacy between Mayweather and Calzaghe?

[Bad_Barracuda]

Floyd-better resume

Calzaghe-better legacy

a legacy of shame

[VERSION1 (V1)]

Floyd only know six people on joe resume

[Addition]

a legacy of shame

21 defences is a shame?

[CardioMonster]

Floyd on paper but I prefer Calzaghe as a fighter, i dont think he ducks people like Floyd does and comes to fight against his opponents, unlike Floyd.

[Technical_Skill]

**** me, why does it come to this?

So we compare the greatest fighter of his generation, a 5 weight world champion with arguebaly the best skillset of the modern era.

With a World class fighter who has fought 1 p4p fighter his entire career, got knocked down, missed all night long, and got one of the most contraversial split decisions of the year.

It shouldnt even be up for discussion.

[QUISQUEYA]

Mayweather isn't a five division champ, he's been a five division titleholder. He picks the weakest titleholder in each division and fights them (Baldomir, Gatti) and avoids the best at eash weight class at the time (Morales 130, Mosley 135, Tszyu 140, Cotto 147 and Forrest 154).
:

Were Morales and Mayweather in the same weight class?

Didn't Mosley move up from 135 before FMJ got there?

[QUISQUEYA]

**** me, why does it come to this?

So we compare the greatest fighter of his generation, a 5 weight world champion with arguebaly the best skillset of the modern era.

With a World class fighter who has fought 1 p4p fighter his entire career, got knocked down, missed all night long, and got one of the most contraversial split decisions of the year.

It shouldnt even be up for discussion.

At 43 years old, BHop didn't have stamina or hunger for a full fight.

[SkillspayBills]

I think this is close than what many might think. Calzaghe has defended his 168 lb title 21 times and is a 2 division champ with wins over Lacy, Hopkins, Eubank, Kessler, Veit and Sheikha.

While Mayweather has defended his 130 lb title 9 times and is a 5 division champ at 130, 135, 140, 147 and 154 with wins over Corrales, Castillo, Hatton, Judah, De La Hoya and Hernandez.

Calzaghe has beaten 8 former world champions while Mayweather has beaten 14 former world champions.

Calzaghe has been in the P4P List for almost an year while Floyd has been in the P4P List since 2000 (8 Years) and #1 since 2005 (3 years).

Both have been world champions for 10 years and both are good fighters.

Every category you just posted Floyd is doing better than Calzaghe is.

[Easy-E]

I really don't see how people can completely **** on Calzaghe's resume while at the same time they defend Mayweathers.

Floyd has faced 14 world champions, thats why.

[Sealhound]

Lmfao that name always gets me Tokker Pudwell, lmfao sounds like a village hall bum fighter lmfao. Mayweather takes this one by a mile.

Common Calzaghe Nuthuggers, I'm English and I love Calzaghe and watching him fight (gave Kessler a lesson) but Floyd would be 1000-0 by now if he fought Tukker Pudwell's to defend his Frank Warren be....I mean WBO belt.